'In Memory Of' is amazing according to Allmetalresources.com! 
"To Cast A Shadow from Hamar, Norway are gothic metal with integrity, and I say that with great severity. Artists like UnSun and Delain, whom are definitely similar, are also much more melodic and, dare I say, poppier than To Cast A Shadow. In Memory Of, the bands second full length, echoes the bleakness of black metal (like I said, this is REAL goth), with the sweet sounds of Gunnhild Huser who provides an innocent aspect to the darkness that inhabits this album. Truly, this is a remarkable effort.
Equally memorable, while not blatant, are the melodies throughout the record. Goth, clearly demarcating itself from the brutality of the extremes existent in black metal, co-habitates itself with the swells of beauty to make sure listeners understand this isnt about nihilism, this is about human suffering and sadness, which in my opinion is a much more somber topic than outright hatred, violence or nihilism. To Cast A Shadow does a brilliant job providing its listeners with a full palette of emotional songs that are substantiated primarily by the melodies sung with great care by Gunnhild. Of course, this isnt to take anything away from the rest of the band who artfully tear apart the human soul with melancholy, spurred on by moments of sudden rage which is all existent within the human self.
This album is about pure passion, simple as that. Theres nothing flashy about In Memory Of, its pure goth, the way goth was meant to be played. Some have criticized female fronted goth outfits for pandering to the Evanescence crowd, which is true in some respect, but make no mistake, To Cast A Shadow have crafted a memorable record for the hardcore metal head, and while I can only speak for myself, I can say I truly appreciate the effort. AMAZING" [Cody]
Link:
http://allmetalresource.com/2011/04/05/review-to-cast-a-shadow-in-memory-of-2011/

"To Cast A Shadow from Hamar, Norway are gothic metal with integrity, and I say that with great severity. Artists like UnSun and Delain, whom are definitely similar, are also much more melodic and, dare I say, poppier than To Cast A Shadow. In Memory Of, the bands second full length, echoes the bleakness of black metal (like I said, this is REAL goth), with the sweet sounds of Gunnhild Huser who provides an innocent aspect to the darkness that inhabits this album. Truly, this is a remarkable effort.
Equally memorable, while not blatant, are the melodies throughout the record. Goth, clearly demarcating itself from the brutality of the extremes existent in black metal, co-habitates itself with the swells of beauty to make sure listeners understand this isnt about nihilism, this is about human suffering and sadness, which in my opinion is a much more somber topic than outright hatred, violence or nihilism. To Cast A Shadow does a brilliant job providing its listeners with a full palette of emotional songs that are substantiated primarily by the melodies sung with great care by Gunnhild. Of course, this isnt to take anything away from the rest of the band who artfully tear apart the human soul with melancholy, spurred on by moments of sudden rage which is all existent within the human self.
This album is about pure passion, simple as that. Theres nothing flashy about In Memory Of, its pure goth, the way goth was meant to be played. Some have criticized female fronted goth outfits for pandering to the Evanescence crowd, which is true in some respect, but make no mistake, To Cast A Shadow have crafted a memorable record for the hardcore metal head, and while I can only speak for myself, I can say I truly appreciate the effort. AMAZING" [Cody]
Link:
http://allmetalresource.com/2011/04/05/review-to-cast-a-shadow-in-memory-of-2011/