Track # by track # - Best Opeth?

1.In Mist She Was Standing/Advent/Prologue/The Moor/The Leper Affinity/Wreath/Windowpane/Ghost Of Perdition/Coil
2.Under The Weeping Moon/The Night And The Silent Water/April Ethereal/Godhead's Lament/Bleak/Deliverance/In My Time Of Need/The Baying Of The Hounds/Heir Apparent
3.Silhouette/Nectar/When/Benighted/Harvest/A Fair Judgement/Death Whispered A Lullaby/Beneath The Mire/The Lotus Eater
4.Forest Of October/Black Rose Immortal/Madrigal/Moonlapse Vertigo/The Drapery Falls/For Absent Friends/Closure/Atonement/Burden
5.The Twilight Is My Robe/To Bid You Farewell/The Amen Corner/Face Of Melinda/Dirge For November/Master's Apprentices/Hope Leaves/Harlequin Forest/Porcelain Heart
6.Requiem/Demon Of The Fall/Serenity Painted Death/The Funeral Portrait/By The Pain I See In Others/To Ride The Disease/Hours Of Wealth/Hessian Peel
7.The Apostle In Triumph/Credence/White Cluster/Patterns In The Ivy/Ending Credits/The Grand Conjuration/Hex Omega
8.Karma/Blackwater Park/Weakness/Isolation Years
9.Epilogue

:)

You have even more time on your hands than the other people who replied to this post :u-huh:
 
1.hope leaves
2.the grand conjuration
3.porcelein heart
4.in my time of need
5.demon of the fall
6.bleak
7.deliverance
8.to rid the disease
9.harlequin forest
10.dirge for november
............umm,it was hard :/......it goes forever...

Methinks you didn't quite get the gist of the thread. Re-read the original post and I think you'll understand :)
 
1st - The Leper Affinity
2nd - The Baying of the Hounds
3rd - A Fair Judgement
4th - The Drapery Falls
5th - Master's Apprentices
6th - Hessian Peel
7th - White Cluster
8th - Blackwater Park

T H I S !


Absolutely fantastic list. I'm sure at least 7 of those would have ended up in my list, even if I had not seen yours. But there is no need for me to do one now, for you did it for both of us, lol.
 
Blaergh, I've changed my mind (again).

1. Wreath
2. Heir Apparent
3. Beneath The Mire
4. Black Rose Immortal
5. Dirge For November
6. Hessian Peel
7. Ending Credits
8. Isolation Years
9. Bridge Of Sighs
10. Circle Of The Tyrant
11. Remember Tomorrow

....and the 'worst' list:

1. In Mist She Was Standing
2. Godhead's Lament
3. Silohuette
4. For Absent Friends
5. Porcelain Heart
6. Eternal Soul Torture
7. The Apostle In Triumph
8. Into The Frost Of Winter
9. Epilogue
10. Den Ständiga Resan
11. Remeber Tomorrow

:rock:
 
1.In Mist She Was Standing/Advent/Prologue/The Moor/The Leper Affinity/Wreath/Windowpane/Ghost Of Perdition/Coil
2.Under The Weeping Moon/The Night And The Silent Water/April Ethereal/Godhead's Lament/Bleak/Deliverance/In My Time Of Need/The Baying Of The Hounds/Heir Apparent
3.Silhouette/Nectar/When/Benighted/Harvest/A Fair Judgement/Death Whispered A Lullaby/Beneath The Mire/The Lotus Eater
4.Forest Of October/Black Rose Immortal/Madrigal/Moonlapse Vertigo/The Drapery Falls/For Absent Friends/Closure/Atonement/Burden
5.The Twilight Is My Robe/To Bid You Farewell/The Amen Corner/Face Of Melinda/Dirge For November/Master's Apprentices/Hope Leaves/Harlequin Forest/Porcelain Heart
6.Requiem/Demon Of The Fall/Serenity Painted Death/The Funeral Portrait/By The Pain I See In Others/To Ride The Disease/Hours Of Wealth/Hessian Peel
7.The Apostle In Triumph/Credence/White Cluster/Patterns In The Ivy/Ending Credits/The Grand Conjuration/Hex Omega
8.Karma/Blackwater Park/Weakness/Isolation Years
9.Epilogue

:)

epic win:kickass:
 
1.Master's Apprentices
2.Blackrose Immortal
3.Harvest
4.The drapery falls
5.Blackwater Park
6.Pattern in the ivy II
7.Porcelain Heart
8.The Grand Conjuration
 
In brackets are the runner-ups for each track number

1. Wreath [The Leper Affinity]
2. Heir Apparent [Deliverance]
3. The Lotus Eater [A Fair Judgment]
4. The Drapery Falls [Black Rose Immortal]
5. Face of Melinda [Dirge For November]
6. Hessian Peel or Demon of the Fall [By The Pain I See in Others]
 
1. The Moor
2. Deliverance/April Ethereal
3. When
4. Closure
5. Master's Apprentices
6. Demon of the Fall/Serenity Painted Death
7. The Apostle In Triumph
8. Blackwater Park
 
1st:The leper affinity
2nd:Under the weeping moon (a hard one since i think my favourite track on each album tends to be the 2nd)
3rd:When
4th:Moonlapse vertigo
5th:To bid you farewell
6th:The funeral portrait
7th:White cluster
8th:Blackwater park
9th:Epilogue
 
1) Advent...or Coil (for its value as an opener)
2) Deliverance
3) Benighted (this was really a hard one...i can't tell you how many times i've listened to the lotus eater since it came out. especially the breakdown :-D)
4) The Drapery Falls
5) To Bid You Farewell
6) Demon Of The Fall (I almost put Hours of Wealth...seems like I might be the only person who even likes that track.)
7) Hex Omega
8) Isolation Years
9) Epilogue (funny...I just realized how there's never been another Opeth track 9.)

Klämrisk;7459975 said:
....and the 'worst' list:

I agree.
Except eternal soul torture is not a real track.
 
Gee.. toughy.

1. The Moor
2. Under the Wheeping Moon
3. When
4. Black Rose Immortal
5. Dirge for November/ To Bid You Farewell (would win prly)
6. Hours of Wealth
7. The Apostle in Triumph
8. Blackwater Park
 
1. Windowpane
2. Bleak
3. Harvest
4. Moonlapse Vertigo/Burden (tie)
5. Harlequin Forest
6. Demon of the Fall
7. Ending Credits

On Track 2, there was a 5-way tie between Bleak, IMToN, Heir Apparent, Godhead's Lament, and BotH. I went with Bleak, though. Why are my fav. tracks number 2 on every CD? Dammit!
 
1. The Moor
2. Godhead's Lament
3. When
4. Moonlapse Vertigo
5. The Twilight Is My Robe
6. Hessian Peel
7. The Apostle In Triumph
8.Karma
9.Epilogue

:)[/QUOTE]
 
1. The Leper Affinity (The Moor)
2. Heir Apparent (Bleak)
3. The Lotus Eater (Harvest)
4. Moonlapse Vertigo (The Drapery Falls)
5. Masters Apprentices (Reverie/Harlequin Forest)
6. The Funeral Portrait (Hessian Peel)
7. White Cluster (The Grand Conjuration)
8. Blackwater Park (Derelict Herds?)
 
1st-Wreath
2nd- The baying of the hounds
3rd- A fair judgement
4th-The drapery falls
5th- To bid you farewell
6th- To rid the disease
7th- Hex Omega/White Cluster
8th- Blackwater Park