Van Roth vs Van Hagar

Van Roth vs Van Hagar

  • Diamond David!!!!

    Votes: 6 42.9%
  • Sammy Hagar

    Votes: 8 57.1%

  • Total voters
    14
BGK I don't think Roth would be better now, nor would I rather see them reunite with Roth than with Hagar now, as Eddie said, Roth can't sing anymore.

The question of this poll was simply this: Which ERA OF VAN HALEN was better... 1978-1984 or 1986-1995. And for me, I have to go with the era that had 5 great albums and my favourite frontman at his best, over the era with 1 great album.

I agree that Hagar is an awesome singer but he doesn't stand out ABOVE that crowd of great singers like Roth stands on his own as a frontman.