Bound2Fate
Member
And just to prove how impossible it is to get people to totally agree on music can be shown right here. Granted, I did not become a fan of Katatonia until THE GREAT COLD DISTANCE but if I would have heard LAST FAIR DEAL GONE DOWN or even VIVA EMPTINESS first, then I guarantee that I would not be here right now. The most important element in ANY band I listen to is the vocals. If I am not feeling the vocals in a band then the band as a whole loses my attention.
Just one example? Novembre. I think musically, they are even better than Katatonia. However, their vocalist is no where near as good a vocalist as Jonas is, thus Katatonia comes out on top. But Jonas just became appealing to me on TGCD. He is now doing something different with his vocals than he did on all their previous albums and it works extremely well. He uses a much more soothing/layered vocal style and uses the melisma techniques more and it made his vocals improve infinitely more than they used to be. After hearing the masterpiece TGCD, I went back and checked out LFDGD hoping to hear these same amazing vocals and they were sadly no where to be found. He improved slightly on VE but still nowhere near as amazing as he is today. And for me, from the songs I have heard thus far from NIGHT IS THE NEW DAY, I can safely say that NITND will possibly surpass TGCD but I can guarantee it will easily slaughter anything else that Katatonia has already made previously. In fact it already has just with the 4 songs I have heard.
Five years ago I would have laughed my ass off if someone would have told me that the Cookie Monster vocals band I had heard several years earlier would now be making such beautifully melodic and soothing rock music as they now make today (and actually become one of my top favorite bands with just one album). TGCD blew me away and I couldn't get enough of that material. I am thrilled to hear that they are keeping that overall style and just expanding upon it on NITND. So yes, in my opinion, TGCD and NITND stand alone and far above anything else that Katatonia has ever made before.
Jack
I used to be the same way. I got into Katatonia with TGCD too and thought everything before was too boring especially because of the vocals. I couldn't get half way through Tonight's Decision and Discouraged Ones. But I kept giving their older albums a try here and there and now I like all of them. Discouraged Ones is even one of my favorites of theirs. Now I laugh at myself for not getting into their older stuff earlier. They're at a point for me now where I'll like anything they put out prolly and I already preordered the Swedish edition of NITND.
I don't think reviews will be necessary for NITND judging from the 4 songs I heard as well.