ronjarz said:
Honestly, I think people complain about Jason because it's the popular thing to do. The old "jump on the bandwagon" thing.
Errrr. "OK." That comes off as a bit arrogant, but then again people always tell me I come off arrogant, so... that's fine hehe. I can't speak for others, but I've never jumped on a bandwagon, ever, and actually, to me it's surprising that so many actually seem to like his vocals... I guess that shows how relative everything is, hehe. I'm having a hard time finding this bandwagon of which you speak, actually...
I
could try to (unsuccessfully) explain why I, personally, do not like his vocals (remember, it's only about his vocals, he seems like a smart, good guy when reading/watching interviews), but since you (Ron) already stated you don't understand why people don't like his vocals, it's sort of no use (and that's fine).
But OK, a few sentences maybe?
Mostly, it's about his voice (or lack thereof), but it's also about the vocal melodies, I'd say. On pitch? Aye, I guess. Yeah. But there's more about vocals than just being on pitch. I find his singing to be very grating and abrasive. You mentioned you grew up on Rush, and, I really can't stand Geddy "squealing pig" Lee either, so there you have it

People are of course entitled to like Jason's vocals; I just don't. To use the worst cliché ever, everyone's taste is different, and it's just too bad ours aren't the same. I don't like Alan Tecchio's vocals either, oh no
Postscriptum: As I said in another thread, I really dislike most singers, and I end up having to filter them away to get at the really good music... However, there is something with McMaster's vocals that just make them pass through my filters, unfiltered... Anyway, it's OK that I can't enjoy
Ink Compatible, because
Ink Complete and
SSoTC and
PHHHP! are just as good as they've ever been, if not better, and I'm not here to insult Ron or anyone else involved in the album, because I think it's pretty poor taste to do that on official forums. I guess my signature might be taken that way, but... it just means that I really love the music on
Ink Compatible (and that I would like to find a way to enjoy it to the max). Actually, I think it'd be great if artists released the raw audio (on say, a DVD) so people could do their own mixes. If it turns out to be feasible, I'd like to do that whenever I release my stuff... it could be under a Creative Commons license or the actual GPL or somesuch, so no one could make money on it. Daring? Yeah. Cool? Hell yeah!
Oh, also... I don't really like cookie monster vocals either, but I found out, after a while, that it's much easier to filter those out, and just treat them as another percussive instrument. So nowadays I actually prefer that, when artists decide they need to have vocals. Instrumental is always king for me, though.