2006 OPETH POLL - SECOND ROUND

[winters epilogue]

Although you said only the first fifty will be counted, I am going to do it anyways. Some of these were really tough.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
LINDGREN BRACKET

1. Bleak vs 8. The Amen Corner = Bleak
2. Black Rose Immortal vs 7. White Cluster = White Cluster
3. Godhead's Lament vs 6. Master's Apprentices = Master's Apprentices
4. A Fair Judgement vs 5. The Baying Of The Hounds = The Baying of the Hounds

LOPEZ BRACKET

1. When vs 8. Hope Leaves = When
2. The Moor vs 7. The Twilight Is My Robe = The Moor
3. The Drapery Falls vs 6. Face Of Melinda = The Drapery Falls
4. In The Mist She Was Standing vs 5. To Bid You Farewell = In Mist She was Standing

MENDEZ BRACKET

1. Ghost Of Perdition vs 9. The Funeral Portrait = Ghost of Perdition
2. Demon Of The Fall vs 7. Wreath = Demon of the Fall
3. Advent vs 6. Closure = Advent
4. The Leper Affinity vs. 5. Moonlapse Vertigo = Moonlapse Vertigo

WIBERG BRACKET

1. Deliverance vs 9. Harvest = Deliverance
2. April Ethereal vs 7. Serenity Painted Death = April Ethereal
3. Blackwater Park vs 6. The Night And The Silent Water = Blackwater Park
4. Reverie/Harelquin Forest vs 5. Windowpane = Windowpane

 

[Kir-ir-Bannog]

LINDGREN BRACKET

1. Bleak vs 8. The Amen Corner = Bleak
2. Black Rose Immortal vs 7. White Cluster = Black Rose Immortal
3. Godhead's Lament vs 6. Master's Apprentices = Masters Apprentices
4. A Fair Judgement vs 5. The Baying Of The Hounds = Baying Of The Hounds

LOPEZ BRACKET

1. When vs 8. Hope Leaves = When
2. The Moor vs 7. The Twilight Is My Robe = The Moor
3. The Drapery Falls vs 6. Face Of Melinda = Face Of Melinda
4. In The Mist She Was Standing vs 5. To Bid You Farewell = To Bid You Farewell

MENDEZ BRACKET

1. Ghost Of Perdition vs 9. The Funeral Portrait = Ghost Of Peridition
2. Demon Of The Fall vs 7. Wreath = Demon Of The Fall
3. Advent vs 6. Closure = Advent
4. The Leper Affinity vs. 5. Moonlapse Vertigo = Leper Affinity

WIBERG BRACKET

1. Deliverance vs 9. Harvest = Deliverance
2. April Ethereal vs 7. Serenity Painted Death = Serenity Painted Death
3. Blackwater Park vs 6. The Night And The Silent Water = Blackwater Park
4. Reverie/Harelquin Forest vs 5. Windowpane = Reverie/Harlequin

 

[byrne]

LINDGREN BRACKET

1. Bleak vs 8. The Amen Corner = Bleak
2. Black Rose Immortal vs 7. White Cluster = Black Rose Immortal
3. Godhead's Lament vs 6. Master's Apprentices = Godhead's Lament
4. A Fair Judgement vs 5. The Baying Of The Hounds = A Fair Judgement

LOPEZ BRACKET

1. When vs 8. Hope Leaves = When
2. The Moor vs 7. The Twilight Is My Robe = The Twilight is my Robe
3. The Drapery Falls vs 6. Face Of Melinda = The Drapery Falls
4. In The Mist She Was Standing vs 5. To Bid You Farewell = In Mist She was Standing

MENDEZ BRACKET

1. Ghost Of Perdition vs 9. The Funeral Portrait = The Funeral Portrait
2. Demon Of The Fall vs 7. Wreath = Demon Of The Fall
3. Advent vs 6. Closure = Advent
4. The Leper Affinity vs. 5. Moonlapse Vertigo = Leper Affinity

WIBERG BRACKET

1. Deliverance vs 9. Harvest = Deliverance
2. April Ethereal vs 7. Serenity Painted Death = April Ethereal
3. Blackwater Park vs 6. The Night And The Silent Water = The Night and the Silent Water
4. Reverie/Harelquin Forest vs 5. Windowpane = Windowpane

 

[Hypnos]

LINDGREN BRACKET

1. Bleak vs 8. The Amen Corner = The Amen Corner
2. Black Rose Immortal vs 7. White Cluster = Black Rose Immortal
3. Godhead's Lament vs 6. Master's Apprentices = Godhead's Lament
4. A Fair Judgement vs 5. The Baying Of The Hounds = A Fair Judgement

LOPEZ BRACKET

1. When vs 8. Hope Leaves = When
2. The Moor vs 7. The Twilight Is My Robe = The Twilight is my Robe
3. The Drapery Falls vs 6. Face Of Melinda = The Drapery Falls
4. In The Mist She Was Standing vs 5. To Bid You Farewell = In Mist She was Standing

MENDEZ BRACKET

1. Ghost Of Perdition vs 9. The Funeral Portrait = Ghost Of Perdition
2. Demon Of The Fall vs 7. Wreath = Demon Of The Fall
3. Advent vs 6. Closure = Advent
4. The Leper Affinity vs. 5. Moonlapse Vertigo = Moonlapse Vertigo

WIBERG BRACKET

1. Deliverance vs 9. Harvest = Harvest
2. April Ethereal vs 7. Serenity Painted Death = April Ethereal
3. Blackwater Park vs 6. The Night And The Silent Water = The Night and the Silent Water
4. Reverie/Harelquin Forest vs 5. Windowpane = Reverie/Harlequin Forest

 

[Tubbs]

Wow, we're a $1.00 bus ride apart.

Woah, and I live only 20 minutes away! My dad goes to work in Dover! (I live in Sanford)

 

[Benighted Joe]

Yeah my second round choices (I know I'm late with my response but I have been with you from the start!):

LINDGREN BRACKET

1. Bleak vs 8. The Amen Corner = Bleak
2. Black Rose Immortal vs 7. White Cluster = Black Rose Immortal
3. Godhead's Lament vs 6. Master's Apprentices = Godhead's Lament
4. A Fair Judgement vs 5. The Baying of The Hounds = The Baying of The Hounds

LOPEZ BRACKET

1. When vs 8. Hope Leaves = When
2. The Moor vs 7. The Twilight Is My Robe = The Moor
3. The Drapery Falls vs 6. Face of Melinda = Face of Melinda
4. In The Mist She Was Standing vs 5. To Bid You Farewell = To Bid You Farewell

MENDEZ BRACKET

1. Ghost of Perdition vs 9. The Funeral Portrait = Ghost of Perdition
2. Demon of The Fall vs 7. Wreath = Wreath
3. Advent vs 6. Closure = Closure
4. The Leper Affinity vs. 5. Moonlapse Vertigo = Moonlapse Vertigo

WIBERG BRACKET

1. Deliverance vs 9. Harvest = Deliverance
2. April Ethereal vs 7. Serenity Painted Death = Serenity Painted Death - (Damn, hard one)
3. Blackwater Park vs 6. The Night And The Silent Water = Blackwater Park
4. Reverie/Harlequin Forest vs 5. Windowpane = Reverie/Harlequin Forest

 

[Disgustipated]

LINDGREN BRACKET

1. Bleak vs 8. The Amen Corner = Bleak
2. Black Rose Immortal vs 7. White Cluster = Black Rose Immortal
3. Godhead's Lament vs 6. Master's Apprentices = Godhead's Lament
4. A Fair Judgement vs 5. The Baying of The Hounds = The Baying of The Hounds

LOPEZ BRACKET

1. When vs 8. Hope Leaves = When
2. The Moor vs 7. The Twilight Is My Robe = The Moor
3. The Drapery Falls vs 6. Face of Melinda = Face of Melinda
4. In The Mist She Was Standing vs 5. To Bid You Farewell = To Bid You Farewell

MENDEZ BRACKET

1. Ghost of Perdition vs 9. The Funeral Portrait = Ghost of Perdition
2. Demon of The Fall vs 7. Wreath = Wreath
3. Advent vs 6. Closure = Closure
4. The Leper Affinity vs. 5. Moonlapse Vertigo = Moonlapse Vertigo

WIBERG BRACKET

1. Deliverance vs 9. Harvest = Deliverance
2. April Ethereal vs 7. Serenity Painted Death = Serenity Painted Death
3. Blackwater Park vs 6. The Night And The Silent Water = Blackwater Park
4. Reverie/Harlequin Forest vs 5. Windowpane = Reverie/Harlequin Forest

------------------------------------------------

Yeah Joe, I changed nothing.

 

[Benighted Joe]

Yeah Joe, I changed nothing.

Yeah Mike! We got something called taste. But it's not fair because I love almost all songs but in different ways... But when forced these were my choices.

Too bad our votes will not be counted

 

[wwallinga]

Okay - we're done with Round 2. I didn't count anybody after Kir, but the only contest that was close was In Mist vs To Bid, and the outcome would have been the same had I kept the last 4 votes anyways.

Here are the results:

LINDGREN BRACKET

1. Bleak over 8. The Amen Corner (46-4)
2. Black Rose Immortal over 7. White Cluster (32-18)
3. Godhead's Lament over 6. Master's Apprentices (30-20)
4. A Fair Judgement upset by 5. The Baying of The Hounds (29-21)

LOPEZ BRACKET

1. When over 8. Hope Leaves (41-9)
2. The Moor over 7. The Twilight Is My Robe (34-16)
3. The Drapery Falls over 6. Face of Melinda (37-13)
4. In The Mist She Was Standing over 5. To Bid You Farewell (26-24)

MENDEZ BRACKET

1. Ghost of Perdition over 9. The Funeral Portrait (39-11)
2. Demon of The Fall over 7. Wreath (43-7)
3. Advent over 6. Closure (34-16)
4. The Leper Affinity over 5. Moonlapse Vertigo (30-20)

WIBERG BRACKET

1. Deliverance over 9. Harvest (37-13)
2. April Ethereal over 7. Serenity Painted Death (35-15)
3. Blackwater Park over 6. The Night And The Silent Water (35-15)
4. Reverie/Harlequin Forest over 5. Windowpane (34-16)

*******************************************

Damnation has been officially eliminated from the competition. Each of the remaining albums still have at least one song! I guess that shows the depth of Opeth's catalog...

I will start a new thread for the third round picks. See you there...

 

[AnTz0r]

Damn... Moonlapse Vertigo is out.

Didn't expect The Amen Corner to get beaten that easily.

Good thing Damnation is out, we can't let an experiment rule us

I'm actually surprised that MA got 20 votes over Godhead... Godhead was such a favorite.