3 mixes of same song - "Collisions In The Sea" (post-rock Mogwai-type stuff)

[schismatic]

Evening all,

Would appreciate thoughts on the following three mixes of a song I've just written and recorded called "Collisions In The Sea".

I'll post details of recording if anybody is interested, but I'd like some thoughts on the 3 mixes I've done of it so far - I can't decide which I like after listening from various sources and using various pieces of equipment (i.e. in-ear headphones, cans, though my phone, through car radio etc).

The three mixes:

Mix 1:



Mix 2:



Mix 3:



Cheers for listening!

Tom

 

[dr.distortion]

Hi Tom, how are you? Nice music! As for me, I like the first version for it clearance and the second one for it's assertive sound. Don't like mix 3, sorry, it sounds a bit lifeless for me.

 

[Siguros]

Not a bad track man! I prefer mix two, it sounds more alive to me The track itself doesn't seem to be pumping, have you stuck a limiter on it and some compression and general EQ in mastering?