Lets see, its kind of hard to remember (it didn't help that I didn't help that I only bought Pale Folklore that night at the show), but heres the ones I do remember:
They opened with that part from She Painted Fire... pt 1 where theres that warlike drum rhythem being beated over and over and they burned incence (which was from the wood called agalloch actualy). At other points they played some of the other portions of She Painted Fire... I remember they did Dead Winter Days which was awesome. They did Odal, which used to bore me, but I realy liked it live. I think they did "You Were a Ghost in My Arms" but I could be wrong there. Now the two highlights: "In the Shadow of Our Pale Companion" was amazing. You know that soft part, where they sing "I walked down to a river..." they made that part heavy with screamed vocals, damn that sounded great. They closed with "The Lodge" on elcectric guitars. It just got more and more intence until it just peaked (sorta think of how The Hawthorne Passage sounds) at which point they threw their intsruments all over the place. Cliched? Yes. Effective? Yes? It was truly an excellent show, especailly when I remember it was their 3rd live performance ever. I can't wait to see them again, hope they play some new stuff at the east coast shows (I've been hearing rumors of a new album, though I've had no ligit facts to back that up...)