AIC new album?

Deadline

Deadline

Member
Aug 30, 2006
152
2
18
Costa Rica
I know for most of the people Alice in Chains is not a metal band, however, I think Facelift and Dirt had a lot of influences in Black Sabbath and Led Zeppelin, so that´s why i submit this thread here... Anyway, whats your opinnion about this new singer and the album comin out soon?, thank you:kickass:
 
Looking forward to it. If new AIC is half as good as Jerry Cantrell's solo albums, then I'll be happy.
 
it will probably be good but its a stupid idea to replace layne. this isn't like ac/dc or iron maiden who were not a hugely successful band and replaced a singer. its not like iron maiden (again) or van halen where the singer supposedly left on his own free will. layne died and that should have been the end of AIC
 
mdmatt4ever said:
it will probably be good but its a stupid idea to replace layne. this isn't like ac/dc or iron maiden who were not a hugely successful band and replaced a singer. its not like iron maiden (again) or van halen where the singer supposedly left on his own free will. layne died and that should have been the end of AIC
Click to expand...

I'm not sure I get you. Bon Scott died. If the difference is popularity at the time then I still don't get it.

It will be no different to me whether they call it AIC or something else. I look forward to it.
 
Wheezer said:
It will be no different to me whether they call it AIC or something else. I look forward to it.
Click to expand...

Only difference is that they'll sell a lot more albums by having AIC on the cover, instead of some other new name.
 
I know for most of the people Alice in Chains is not a metal band
Click to expand...

They most absolutely were. The first 2 records were quite heavy (especially facelift). They were certainly the most metal of the big 3 (Soundgarden and Pearl Jam).

Anyways, I think it can be decent. If it's at least as good as the lackluster S/T CD, I'll be happy.
 
I'll buy it and hope for the best. I'm not too fond of Cantrell's solo stuff. He's not a good solo artist, I like him better in the supporting role. He provided great background vocals, excellent riffs and co-wrote some classic stuff...with Alice In Chains.I'm curious how he works with Duvall, will it work as well as it he did with Staley? We'll have to wait and see...
 
sixxswine said:
I'll buy it and hope for the best. I'm not too fond of Cantrell's solo stuff. He's not a good solo artist, I like him better in the supporting role. He provided great background vocals, excellent riffs and co-wrote some classic stuff...with Alice In Chains.I'm curious how he works with Duvall, will it work as well as it he did with Staley? We'll have to wait and see...
Click to expand...
Gotta disagree with you on that one -- I thought both of his solo albums were brilliant.
 
Wheezer said:
I'm not sure I get you. Bon Scott died. If the difference is popularity at the time then I still don't get it.

It will be no different to me whether they call it AIC or something else. I look forward to it.
Click to expand...


when bon scott died ac/dc had just broken through from cult band to a mainstream band. if ac/dc had been a hugely successful band for 6-8 years before bon died they shouldn't have replaced him either.

if jerry cantrell said something like "layne has until 2003 to get his act together or we'll continue without him" then i wouldn't care but it seems to me like they just waited around until layne died and then reformed AIC.
 
mdmatt4ever said:
when bon scott died ac/dc had just broken through from cult band to a mainstream band. if ac/dc had been a hugely successful band for 6-8 years before bon died they shouldn't have replaced him either.

if jerry cantrell said something like "layne has until 2003 to get his act together or we'll continue without him" then i wouldn't care but it seems to me like they just waited around until layne died and then reformed AIC.
Click to expand...

Fair enough. I see what you're getting at but I disagree. In my opinion it's up to the artist(s) to make that call. It's up to us fans to decide whether it bothers us enough to not buy the product.

Like wdiv said, it'll certainly sell better with the AIC brand on it. If it's a business decision then so be it. The business side of things kinda sucks sometimes.
 
Wheezer said:
Fair enough. I see what you're getting at but I disagree. In my opinion it's up to the artist(s) to make that call. It's up to us fans to decide whether it bothers us enough to not buy the product.

Like wdiv said, it'll certainly sell better with the AIC brand on it. If it's a business decision then so be it. The business side of things kinda sucks sometimes.
Click to expand...

i feel thats the only reason they are calling it AIC
 
Im not a huge fan for some reason though some songs stood out well. Layne had one awesome set of pipes. I dont see where it matters that they go under the AiC name, it is a good business decision and when they tour they will no doubt be playing many of the older songs... so that in itself makes them AiC.
 
I haven't heard his solo albums, but Anger Rising was a fantastic song. That ranks among his finest works - AIC or otherwise. That song could have been in AIC and no one would have been the wiser.

I've always thought Cantrell was a great all around guitarist. Not a shredder, but he had quite a unique writing style.
 
poundingmetal74 said:
Anger Rising was a fantastic song. That ranks among his finest works - AIC or otherwise. That song could have been in AIC and no one would have been the wiser.
Click to expand...

Right I agree. I felt ripped off when I bought that album based on the strength of that song alone. It did in fact sound very closer to AIC. I remember the firast time I saw AIC they had yet released their debut album but opened up Clash Of The Titans. They came out as a three piece. Jerry handled the guitar and vocal duties for the first verse of "Man In The Box" then from the side stage comes Lane! He must have been in the toilet with his rig because he was late! Anyway they didn't miss a beat. Impressive.
 
sixxswine said:
Right I agree. I felt ripped off when I bought that album based on the strength of that song alone. It did in fact sound very closer to AIC. I remember the firast time I saw AIC they had yet released their debut album but opened up Clash Of The Titans. They came out as a three piece. Jerry handled the guitar and vocal duties for the first verse of "Man In The Box" then from the side stage comes Lane! He must have been in the toilet with his rig because he was late! Anyway they didn't miss a beat. Impressive.
Click to expand...

I saw them that year too. Opening for VanHalen "F.U.C.K" tour. I knew I was listening to something different and was kinda impressed. They didnt fly really well with the typical commercial metal fans, I'm not saying nobody found some merit to it but most seemed to have the "WTF?" look on their face. It was different... and the rest is history.
 
They could record tons of albums with the new vocalist, even sell millions. But, IMO, no Layne, no Alice In Chains. A totally personal voice. I don´t see any substitute for him. "Dirt" is one of the best albums from the 90´s. Masterpiece.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

dorian gray
ITT We Discuss AiC
Replies
7
Views
186
RC
En Vind Av Sorg
E
MetalAges
Former ALICE IN CHAINS Bassist Performs With Tribute Band In New York City
Replies
0
Views
135
Metal News 2
MetalAges
M
T
Heavy Metal on Rolling Stones Top 100 album list.
Replies
0
Views
360
Old School Metal Discussion
TheGraveDigger
T
F
ze battle
Replies
21
Views
1K
Nevermore
Dead Winter
D
R
album sales
Replies
22
Views
626
Nevermore
Inner peace
I
Top Bottom
Back