Amazing review of the new Kayo Dot

batmura

Sea of Tranquility
Nov 1, 2001
2,828
4
38
www.seaoftranquility.org
From Amazon.com by the amazing Lord Chimp:

This is a very special band with a lot to share. In hindsight it is obvious from the first Kayo Dot that the band's past "astral metal" incarnation, maudlin of the Well, was not meant to be any point of reference.* The curiously titled _Dowsing Anemone with Copper Tongue_ a fortiori severs the connection to that lovable, obscure band. For one thing, although the instrumental lineup has not changed significantly (guitars, piano/keys, violin, trumpet, drums & percussion, with electronics), the music is virtually bereft of anything I would call metal or prog-rock (or whatever exactly motW was). The vocals turned farther away from the screaming and roaring and more towards schizophrenic and dreamy. The music is much more texturally and melodically based than riff-based, and the music is highly composed. If I may have the liberty of comparison, it sounds a little like an obsessed mutant child of Neurosis, GYBE, and a drugged-up Jeff Buckley, still informed by rock, jazz, classical, and ambient. All the while its structural approach reveals less favor for the Western convention of contrasting sections -- the songs of _Dowsing Anemone..._, most of which being 10 to 15 minutes-plus in length, are slowly-evolving, organic constructions. One must hear it to understand how unique and special this music is.

It begins rather like the first album. "Gemini Becoming Tripod", the first track, sets the album up with its lengthy, spacious arrangements, more 'natural' sound, and otherworldly intimations. It starts with a repetitive, harmonically static guitar being strummed with a more fluid violin accompaniment. This combination is whipped into a tumult then fades away as plaintive vocals and weird lyrics like "Geometry showed me its dark side and showered me with its arcing planes" emerge, delivered with tortured, incomprehensible moaning from Driver, which is beaten around by well-timedstrikes of distorted guitars, reaching through a Gorguts-esque apogee with chaotic violin lines and a squealing guitar solo. And that is only the first song! Then, "Immortelle and Paper Caravelle" could be the post-rock ballad to send lovers everywhere into crazier fits of ardor than Amando and Amanda from Ligeti's great opera _Le grand macabre_. It begins with a seemingly random sparkle of heavily-reverbed guitar notes, gradually given cohesion by the introduction of senuous bass lines and a jazzy drum rhythm. Toby Driver's falsetto vocals, the words totally unintelligible, are so delicate he must be hovering between a state of life and death. He sings some of the most perfect melodic lines recorded before a transition of multi-tracked violin pizzicatos and a simple guitar riff leaves the song to fade out in a blissful web of strings and effects. This beautiful slice of music, which is almost absurdly pretty, set against Kayo Dot's apocalyptic climax on "___ on Limpid Form", suggests a disturbing nonchalance about the clash of doom and beauty. But that's always been a theme of Toby Driver's bands...

"Aura on an Asylum Wall" jerks one out of the dreamy state induced by the previous piece. It starts in a dull cacophony of interlocking pieces of eerie glissandos and drunken half-talking/half-singing. It takes a weird vaudevillian twist with a 9/8 rhythm and trumpet solo, then it almost seems to imperceptibly change as thrusts of sustained tones appear and disappear over a steadily intensifying rhythm speckled with violin flourishes. The guitars start to sound more riff-like until it all explodes in a rash grind of crackling distortion over frantic screaming with really surprising, fast n' funky bass by Ryan McGuire and a crazy percussion track that sounds like it was put together with traditional tape-splicing.

"___ on Limpid Form" starts almost in verse-chorus mode, low, plaintive vocal harmonies singing of "a soundless rapture that dissolves the form." Jazzy horn solos and the weird rhythm make it seem like some kind of underwater fugue. Starting at about 4:50 or 5:00, the song takes a dark and disturbing turn. What starts as a handful of chromatic chords punctuated by tense silences, become more spaced apart, more distorted, and more crushing, until 10 minutes later when it is just slow, periodic strikes of heavily detuned chords from the book of Sunn 0))), each capped by a brutal squeal of feedback and surrounded by mechanical junkyard percussion. When the roaring distortion of "___ on Limpid Form" rolls over into "Amaranth the Peddler", one is humbled by Kayo Dot's masterful resolution. It starts with a very quiet introduction for solo drums rather like "The Ferryman" from motW's _Bath_. It is joined by irregular bassy grumbles that expand and contract for a few minutes before strange, overlapping whistling noises and violins that sound like pitch-bending sirens enter the soundscape. The instrumentation that concludes is complex, arpeggiated chord playing which wafts like an autumn wind through dry leaves. "Amaranth" is an incredibly haunting, strange piece and it ends the album PERFECTLY.

_Dowsing Anemone in Copper Tongue_ is only the second album under the Kayo Dot banner, and so perfect and brilliant that the band may never surpass it.

* if you are at all interested in progressive rock/metal or original music of any kind you must do yourself a favor and hear everything by maudlin of the Well.
 
Excerpt from another review at Amazon:

Now. On to "Dowsing Anemone..." What to say? I literally expected...more. Now, I value experimentation to the utmost, but not when the album or composition suffers because of it.

I could go on, but I think I'll paraphrase my review into this: "This album has its moments. And they are *literally* moments."

^ What a sad fellow. For him music is about moments. For others it's about buildup and representation, that power music has to symbolically represent anything about reality including the mundane time away from the drama or the "moments," which I find a lot more emotionally meaningful. I don't know. I listen to many of the tracks on Dowsing... purely for the details and what not, the environment. Too many people lack the taste. :mad:
 
Helm said:
He's sad because he expects different things from music that you do?


Any reviewer whose expectations are either too narrow and undeveloped or mismatched for the music, and yet doesn't know it, is "sad" to the extent that he is incompetent.

If you want any more lessons, then let me know.
 
Yes, I want more lessons.

Please teach me more about quantifying expectation. You seem to know all about what other people expect from their purchases. Tell me more on how if you expect a balance of dynamics, and actual melodic and harmonic content in your music then obviously your wants are underdeveloped. People should never take chances when they listen to music, they should stick to what they've known to like in the past. And heaven forbid, should they venture outwards and be disappointed in a piece of music, they shouldn't dare mention it in fear of self-professed internet teachers in good taste.
 
Dijon mustard. Whats the big humdrum? I expected more. This shit has its moments (like when I'm drunk). Otherwise, not worth stealing.
 
Helm is a pretty dense guy. Basically I'm praising the band of this board, while criticizing the shallow tastes of a reviewer who makes up more than the norm as far as typical responses to Dowsing goes.

The average response by the average music listener listening to the album consists of complaints relating to "too much experimentation," "not enough melody" or other: "Kayo Dot are gay," "too much jazz," and more idiocy that stems from misexpectation in one form or another, wrapped up in a wordy review that dismisses the worth of the music and claims to be adequate to it but isn't.

That's not just a "right to be personally disappointed in music" issue.
 
Helm is a pretty dense guy.

Yes, that is true, I am not very smart. Thank you for taking the time out of your teaching schedule to illuminate me on the subject.

Basically I'm praising the band of this board, while criticizing the shallow tastes of a reviewer who makes up more than the norm as far as typical responses to Dowsing goes.

Oh now that you give it to me basic-like I get it. Thanks. Get on with criticizing the tastes of the normies, they really need the critical kick in the crotch and you're just the man to do it.
 
Helm said:
Oh now that you give it to me basic-like I get it. Thanks. Get on with criticizing the tastes of the normies, they really need the critical kick in the crotch and you're just the man to do it.

DeliveranceDriver said:
I listen to Kayo Dot therefore I'm a genius, and those who don't listen to/like KAYO DOT are idiots.

I predict the future.
 
give dd a little bit of a break. i dont post here a lot so im not sure how long youve been reading or posting but we've had a lot of these discussions about how different people view the band and what not..so that's i think part of why you are getting a lot of flak.

my attitude is if people like it great and if not, thats cool too as long as they dont say massively mean spirited things or go way way out of their way to attack us personally.
 
I don't enjoy listening to Drowsing very much and I understood pretty early on it is because I expect different things from it than what it's giving, but I don't see how saying this (in a review or in here or whatever) as critique is stupid or one should be mocked for it. I've listened to a lot of different music, I enjoy a great variety of things, I am not ill-equipped to listen to Kayo Dot, and yet still the second record simply isn't for me. That's why I said what I said to DeliveranceDriver. Usually I'm not much for irony, but I found what he said at first an interesting matter of discussion and his following posts just simply insulting.
 
Thanks rachmiel. I appreciate that. :headbang:

For the record, it's not that I'm peevish against those who don't like an album or band as I do. I'm peevish towards those who think there's no fucking way that disagreeing with someone or thinking they are "wrong" about an album can have any substance, especially from those on a board who are supposed to be fans and would know about a band being misunderstood or dismissed.

Of course, it's also possible that someone simply don't like an album. But the usual thing is that they are indeed "ill equipped" to enjoy it. The writer of that review doesn't give me a reason to think otherwise.
 
lololololololololloololololololooololololololoolololoolololijmdrunk

i'd never go out of my way to attack a band with a pretty small fanbase such as kayo dot, but the review that dd is protesting about is hardly a scathing, close-minded criticism of all things adventurous. for fucks sake it ends with the recommendation that people hunt down choirs of the eye.