Battle of the Bands Round 5: Metallica Vs Helloween
- Thread starter Spruce Goose
- Start date
Metallica.
Helloween would probably be my choice if I'd heard more though because they seem to have been more consistent over the years (with the exceptions of Chameleon and Pink Bubbles). Metallica have sucked for 10 years.
Helloween would probably be my choice if I'd heard more though because they seem to have been more consistent over the years (with the exceptions of Chameleon and Pink Bubbles). Metallica have sucked for 10 years.
I went Helloween. I am probably a bigger fan of Metallica's, but I love the long epic Helloween songs like Mission Motherland, Halloween, Kepper of the Seven Keys, The Dark Ride, as well as some of their shorter ones like Eagle Fly Free, if I could Fly, I want Out.... etc.
The only downside:
Mr Torture!
The only downside:
Mr Torture!
Spiff
I have the power
I'm going with Metallica because, unlike what Troops just said, they've been more consistent than Helloween have been 
Still, Helloween had the absolutely awesome "I Want Out", but Metallica had their fair share of great songs too. Metallica gets my vote, though.
Still, Helloween had the absolutely awesome "I Want Out", but Metallica had their fair share of great songs too. Metallica gets my vote, though.
Spiff
I have the power
Oh, and with Helloween, I think Kiske is a better singer than Andi, but the Andi-era material is much, much better than Kiske-era material. But I didn't like The Dark Ride all that much... but Time of the Oath! What an awesome album!!
Metallica do have some awesome songs.
Fade to Black, One, Etc,
I wish they had done Fade to Black witda orchestra!
Fade to Black, One, Etc,
I wish they had done Fade to Black witda orchestra!
I meant that the song The Dark Ride is awesome. The album isnt that great.... but I love the title track.... And If I could Fly
Spiff
I have the power
I wish they had done Fade to Black when I saw them in 1998 Brilliant gig apart from that, though.
Brilliant gig apart from that, though.
How come it is still 50/50 with the votes if 2 of you's have voted Metallica and I voted Halloween?
Spiff
I have the power
I voted for Helloween out of spite. Bloody Metallica and their past decade!!
Take out Pink Bubbles and Chameleon, and I think all of Helloween's work is great.
Can pretty much do the same for Metallica if you take out Load and Reload....
Nah. Helloween.
And personally....I love The Dark Ride. It's no Keeper 1 or 2, but still....
Take out Pink Bubbles and Chameleon, and I think all of Helloween's work is great.
Can pretty much do the same for Metallica if you take out Load and Reload....
Nah. Helloween.
And personally....I love The Dark Ride. It's no Keeper 1 or 2, but still....
Lord Tim
That guy from LORD
Helloween... in spite of the genius of Metallica's earlier albums...
They've been consistently pretty good throughout their career (with the exception of Chameleon! Ugh!) with a few brilliant moments (Keeper I & II, Live In The UK, Better Than Raw, etc.)
They've been consistently pretty good throughout their career (with the exception of Chameleon! Ugh!) with a few brilliant moments (Keeper I & II, Live In The UK, Better Than Raw, etc.)
Blitzkrieg
Master Exploder
Metallica all the way. I can't believe so many people rag on Metallica for what they are doing now. It doesn't change how awesome their earlier shit is...
KoichCPA
Banned
Originally posted by Spruce Goose
The only downside:
Mr Torture!
Thats a great song!
Does anyone else here also prefer Andi Deris over Michael Kiske? I know I certainly do.
Similar threads
