Between the Buried and Me - Colors

I haven't been to Trader Joe's in ages! I don't even know if there's on in the area!!!!!! I'm craving that orange chicken like a mofo.
 
Seriously... how can they be a "shit" band? What about them is so bad? Someone please explain how a band like Between the Buried and Me is "shit" because I'm really having a hard time understanding that sort of logic.