NocturnalSun said:
So the church's past is etched in blood. Who here sins? yeah we ALL do. Don't bring the past up to bring down the current followers. I didn't go and take the lands did I? So it's not my fault cuz I had no say in the matter. I certainly think the inquisition/crusades were totally wrong and never should have happened, but those were commanded by a human, and as you know humans are weak and we tend to make a TON of bad choices. GOD did not tell the pope back then to take the lands by force, in fact he even said 'preach to the cities you come to. Come in and eat with those who accept you, but shake your sandle to those who do not and leave.'
Wait asecond... conquistadores? u mean Cortez and his slaughter of the Aztecs? He was not Christian. He even pretended to be their 'god' just so he can take gold and kill them all (look at a history book). It worked, too.
Anyway, ya I guess this ain't persecution, b ut I had numerous people post in the satanism and metal thread saying to me 'you damn christian, you're all blind, you should die because your beliefs suck, you aren't christian for listening to metal dumbass.' and stuff...
Those attacks weren't necessarily directed at
you, it appeared to me as though they were directed at the religion in general. And while I'm not attacking you, I definately believe 95% of those critiques were justified. Pull a Christian aside and ask him, "Why do you believe what you believe?", and nine times out of ten, by the the time the discourse has ended, they won't have anything solid to stand upon. Christianity (along with most other religions) does
not encourage the questioning of things. And how can one possibly understand it if it is not questioned? Most Christians are Christian not of their choosing, but because it is their
birthright: their parents were Christian and their parents were Christian and their parents were Christian and so forth. Consequently, the newest generation adheres to their religion less because it is a proper spiritual authority and more because they are heirs to their beliefs.
I think one of the best passages exemplifying some of the central weaknesses of the religion lie in Voltaire's
A Plea For Tolerance and Reason, in which he writes the folllowing on Christian Dogma:
"...Is Jesus the Word? If He be the Word, did He emanate from God in time or before time? If He emanated from God, is He co-eternal and cosubstantial with Him, or is He of a similar substance? Is He distinct from Him, or is He not? Is He made or begotten? Can He beget in His turn? Has He paternity? or productive virtue without paternity? Is the Holy Ghost made? or begotten? or produced? or proceeding from the Father? or proceeding from the Son? or proceeding from both? Can He begat? can He produce? is His hypostasis cosubstantial with the hypostasis of the Father and the Son? and how is it that, having the same nature-the same essence as the Father and the Son, He cannot do the same things done by these persons who are Himself? Assuredly, I understand none of this; no one has ever understood any of it, and that is why we have slaughtered one another..."
Again, I'm not attacking you NocturnalSun, don't take it that way. I'm just trying to give you some insight as to why you are being met with some of the criticisms being given to you.