Witch is better. The Iced Earth version of Hallowed be thy name or the Cradle of Filth version. I adore both but find it difficult to place one of the other. Both have their own feeling and soul. Please help. :hotjump:
Cradle of Filth vs Iced Earth
- Thread starter mirrorsin
- Start date
stefan86
invariably off-topic
Even though i like Iced Earth more as a band i gotta say that Cradle made their version of Hallowed more 'unique'.
_(^DRACULA^)_
_(^DRACULA^)_
they both sucked i'm sorry lol but they did lol
the best one is done by Dungeon lol ... stuff the rest lol
i'de like to hear COF cover IE and IE cover COF lol
now that should be interesting lol ...
the best one is done by Dungeon lol ... stuff the rest lol
i'de like to hear COF cover IE and IE cover COF lol
now that should be interesting lol ...
Lies and Perfidy
Gentleman of the Road
I'm with Clarify...Iced Earth's is pretty much the same as the original and is thus redundant, while Cradle of Filth's is just bad. I really don't like that band at all.
FirstStrikeIsDeadly
Fuck my aching tits
asphyXy
Clad in Shadows
iced earth's is a tribute, while cof's is a cover. cof is a sucky band that tried to make an amazing song their own, while iced earth is a great band that paid tribute to a great band.. and did an awesome tribute in the process.
Iced Earth wins.
Iced Earth wins.
asphyXy
Clad in Shadows
Lies and Perfidy
Gentleman of the Road
Nocturnal Emperor
Why so serious ?
_(^DRACULA^)_
_(^DRACULA^)_
well it is true , like in the sence that if i had the choice i'de listen to the IE one lol ...
but still i think IE is better off doing IE ... damn they sound great doing that lol ....
but still i think IE is better off doing IE ... damn they sound great doing that lol ....
theodyssey
Best Album of the Year
CoF did the song better than both IE and Iron Maiden. It's a great song, but it's a fucking dark song and CoF was able to bring that atmosphere of impending doom. Iron maiden's just sounds gay next to it... way too happy.
Tool
The Crimson King
I can't stand the begining of IE's version... it sounds so... blergh, I dunno why Barlow sounds really oafish there, but in the screamy parts it gets r0x0ring. The CoF version sounds kinda funny though. it's more of a novelty, But I gues I kinda like it better. The Iron Maiden One Overall kicks ass.
insidethefall
somewhere nowhere
Solitude Aeturnus covered this and it was f'n incredible, cradle of cheese's version was horrid and i didnt find anything special in the IE version.
sixxswine
rockandrollazine.blogspot
FirstStrikeIsDeadly said:
I would have to totally agree with you on this.
I was wondering why his lack of vocal ability
sounded so familiar? It's from watching Star Wars.
I'm sorry, but I'm not a big fan of Cradle Of Filth.
Nilion
Member
Iced Earths version...Dani is such a crap 'singer' imo, and Matt puts alot emotion in it and they did it as a tribute and did it great.
Psychonaut
God Of Emptiness
Cradle Of Filth hands down. They put their filthy little twist on it and I think did an excellent job with it. Although Iced Earth still did a respectable version, it's too close to the original and if I wanted that, I'd break out the Iron Maiden.
General Dildo
Smeller of flowers
cradles version kicks iced earths version real hard in the ass and dildoes it with a giant dildo!
Blitzkrieg
Master Exploder
IE are one of my favourite bands, and I don't care that much for CoF at all, but I would have to say that I prefer the CoF cover. IE's sounds similar the original, and I much prefer the original, so I would never listen to the IE version. CoF's version is an interesting take on a classic with a personal twist, which I like, and think it makes for a good cover.
Similar threads
