DT Song Survivor - part 1 / round 2

[seventi]

Originally posted by Salamurhaaja


Still voting for the _MOST_ overrated DT song _EVER_, Punish My Heaven.

Why the hell isn't anybody flaming this guy for voting on Punish my heaven. That song is sacred

 

[hyena]

i hated 243.5 some days ago and i still hate it.
i ask you all to reconsider your evil ways against yesterworld. the initial riff was what made me notice dark tranquillity first, and this is important. you have no sensitivity at all, as rahvin quoted.

h

 

[poldarn]

Originally posted by rahvin
i stand my ground, freecard has to go way sooner than yesterworld.

btw, i'm gonna edit the name of the poll 2, round 1 thread so as to make them all alike/clearer, hope you don't mind.

rahvin.

umm, why are you so anti-freecard? I think that song is great, definately one of the best songs on Projector.

 

[rahvin]

Originally posted by poldarn
umm, why are you so anti-freecard? I think that song is great, definately one of the best songs on Projector.

aside from the part where it comes to individual tastes, i can but name a couple of reasons...
i think freecard and therein are very similar. too similar as opposed to the diversity in the other songs on projector. but while therein at least sets some kind of standard of what was - at that time - a new kind of dt song (there weren't many melodic mid-tempoed tracks with stanzas + chorus and a short bridge on tmi or the gallery) freecard just seems to replicate the structure in a less inspired way, without adding anything to the opulence of the other song. plus, there aren't many quips when it comes to melody, at least not that i noticed.

rahvin.

 

[Villain]

Dear dwarf: Although I agree with you about the similarity in structures between FreeCard and ThereIn, I must say that IMHO the latter one is the less inspired one by far. And talking about the quips, for me FreeCard does much more than for example Auctioned or On Your Time - both of which are o.k. songs, but nothing remarkable.

-Villain

 

[Parasite]

Lethe












































Riiiiiiiight. I picked 'Misery In Me'

 

[Phyros]

Well, I don´t like Yesterworld. So...*byebye*

Anyways, Salamurhaaja, we are not voting for the most overrated song here you know... But if we were to do that, I´d chose Hedon. It is _way_ overrated, but still frekkin good...

@Sean... You! Stop voting that godly song! I will kick you butt the first thing I do next summer! If I can reach it, and if you promise not to crush me to goo...

Regarding that Freecard/ThereIn stuff, I must say I agree with what is said, but, the main reason why I find them quite boring is the fact that they where samples for Projector and it was all I had to listen to from that record for a loooooong time. I have simply listened to much to them.

-phyros

 

[Dark_Jester]

Bye bye yesterworld, and may you sink to the bottom without a trace

 

[Master]

Another no night waits its turn so i call upon my FreeCard to postpone

 

[The Grand Wazoo]

Originally posted by seventi
Why the hell isn't anybody flaming this guy for voting on Punish my heaven. That song is sacred

Indeed!

Punish My Heaven is definitely my fav song..
And FOUR people dislike it the most!!

 

[Wanderingblade]

Nevermind Punish for the time being, WHICH BASTARD IS VOTING FOR CONSTANT?

 

[Salamurhaaja]

Good to know Punish My Heaven won't win this one, since Lethe will, even tho I wish it was Through Ebony Archways, but that song is under rated beyond belief.

 

[Villain]

Okay, I guess we can call this poll finished as well, even though only 40 people voted. Anyway, a few more votes wouldn't change anything, so Yesterworld gets voted out this round.

And remember to vote on parts 2 and 4!

-Villain

 

[rahvin]

proceeding to close/unstick this poll...

rahvin.