Evergrey- Monday Morning Apocalypse (review/spoilers inside)

Harvester

The Promoter
Sep 16, 2001
7,727
309
83
www.progpowerusa.com
Ok, let's get something out of the way first before I post my thoughts. I am an Evergrey fanboy. They are my favorite band in the world (ok..behind Buffett). I have enjoyed every single Evergrey disc to date, some more than others. I'm also the promoter of a show in which I booked them as a headliner and I want to sell tickets. There is no way that I can remain purely objective based on all of that. However I make NO apology for it either.

I love this disc. I love it because Evergrey decided to tweak the formula and take some chances while keeping the core sound/vibe in tact. Will some call it a sell-out based on one song? Of course. You can't have a metal fan base without having idiots in it. Will some be disappointed because it doesn't sound like ISoT (or insert your favorite Egrey release). Yes. That's the way metal fans are about beloved releases..obsessive to the point of not being able to enjoy anything new because they want another alien anal probe. Will some love MMA? Absofuckinglutely.

Now, let's get the sonic aspect out of the way. I am no audiophile. I don't go apeshit over the acoustics of the snare sound, the bass reverb, or the dryness of the vocals (whatever the fuck that is). If you are looking for that kind of stuff, head over to Sneap or Kernon's forums and pick their brains once this is released. All I know is that it sounds awesome to me so you may as well stop with the producer bitching. The ingredients are all still there: Tom's vocals, driving rhythm section (drums really have been taken up a notch), haunting piano/keys, riffs and soaring solos galore, and the lovely Carina providing some great backing vocals on several of the choruses.

Spoilers Below:





The following are random thoughts on each of the songs. They are not meant to be coherent, compressive descriptions for the most part. It's just how I felt while listening....

1. Monday Morning Apocalypse- The disc starts out with what is sure to be the most controversial track on the disc. This is the lead single and may indeed bring in the band a new legion of fans. Yes, it has a bit more of a modern feel. As you can tell from the clip, the vocals are processed throughout the verses of the song. I was a bit shocked myself. However, after hearing the entire song they work perfectly because they really enhance the clean chorus. Besides, it's just catchy as hell.

2. Unspeakable- The old guard can relax the sphincter now. This is the traditional Evergrey tune you are looking for. The intense build up is there followed by the pounding melodic chorus. This reminds me of some of the better moments from Recreation Day.

3. Lost- This one goes back to the IsoT formula: quick crunchy intro that slams to a halt with intense vocals backed by the choir. Fantastic. The chorus is a bit lighter than what you may be expect, but that's ok. This is where change is a good thing as it keeps things fresh. Wait till you hear the solo. It's what I call a clean, soaring type instead of some fast technical sweep.

4. Obedience- ROOOOOCCCCKKKKK!!! If the band had posted this as a sound clip, there would be no "hmmm" going on. This is the heaviest tune on the disc. The riffs bitchslap you and the chorus makes no apology afterwards. The shredheads will be happy here as well with the extended dual soloing.

5. The Curtain Fall- A great up-tempo number in the tradition of "Mark of the Triangle." This is another tune where their guitar tone is going to throw some people off.

6. In Remembrance- Doomy with shotgun style lyrics. That makes no sense as I type this, but once you hear it.... I love the lush atmosphere with the piano interlude. Tom's vocals rule.

7. At a Loss for Words- Hello vocal processing...hello awesome fucking song. It's heavy as hell and drips with attitude. This is my favorite chorus on the disc. Ranks right up there with "Obedience" as one of my faves.

8. Till Dagmar- Beautiful piano instrumental.

9. Still in the Water- The most "modern" sounding track as it grooves more than anything. I think you get the idea from the sample on the website.

10. The Dark I Walk You Through- Fuck..the lyrical theme of the disc is dark enough, but this is just despair ("He waved to her and turned, and that was the last time he saw her") The doomy guitar riffs don't lighten things either.

11. I Should- Intense. 'Nuff said.

12. Closure- Tom's most soulful vocal performance to date. It's just him and a piano and that's all it needs. The chill bumps hit me instantly. Hell, even my wife said...he sounds "amazing."


I've said my piece and I'm sure some will disagree with me once they hear the disc. However, music is a personal experience for me. I don't need anyone else's approval in order to love Evergrey.


Cheers,

Glenn H.
__________________
 
Sweeeeeeeeet!!! thanks Glenn!!!

You got married? Congrats!!! Hello??!?!?, where was I for this news? Damn man!!!

Bear
 
I heard the three clips and I made a snap call. Now that I understand you had no say in what we heard, my faith in your review is bolstered.

I trust you to know your shit, Glenn...and I am happy to read this review.

As I said in another post, I am pre-ordering this thing, and then will go to my local music store to buy multiple copies on the day of release, (to raise their profile in the brick and mortar revenue stream--and to give out as gifts), but now I feel much better about the purchase.
 
Sounds great, Glenn. I'm totally positive on the clips. I mean, it's mainstream production (and yes, there are still a lot of averagely produced metal records out there) but with good metal songs. I'm looking foreward to it and I hope it brings them the exposure they hope, 'cause they deserve it.
 
Well, I think it might almost be safe to say that the new Evergrey disc will be to my liking. I like that they are tweaking things a bit. I think Evergrey was due for a slight bit of a changeup. It also sounds like perhaps the best songs might not be the clips that were posted yesterday. I liked those clips for the most part, so I'm guessing I'll remain a happy Evergrey fan.

Thanks for the writeup, Glenn.

Britt
 
The 3 sound clips are only making me salivate for more...

And for the record, EG is one of the few bands I feel I can blindly trust to consistently put out amazing albums. So I didnt need to here the clips or read the spoiler, but how can one resist?
 
Harvester said:
Will some be disappointed because it doesn't sound like ISoT (or insert your favorite Egrey release). Yes. That's the way metal fans are about beloved releases.
I won't jump to any conclusions about this disc, based on three one minute samples, ripped at 128 Kbps. And while I'll most certainly buy this disc (I own every Evergrey release), I can't say that these samples excited me.

In my opinion, neither of the last two CDs have been on par with the two that preceded them. I don't care that neither were concept CDs. Nor do I care that they didn't sound like ISoT or SDT. They simply weren't as good. Were they very good discs? Yes (IC more so than RD, which for me, is their weakest). However, while Evergrey's songwriting has grown more mature, there's an element that's been lost during that maturation process. It's not a matter of those discs being "less Metal". They've lost that dark, foreboding element that made Evergrey so interesting. And while that dark vibe is hardly the only element of Evergrey's sound that separates them from the pack, I believe it's why the last two releases have met with less adulation.

Zod
 
Evergrey releasing a sub-par disc? Not fucking likely! I too heard the clips and did not reserve judgement,because they never fail to kick you in the nuts when the disc comes out.
Remember the sample from Fates Warnings last? "Simple Human" was by far the worst track they could have let out. It showed us no growth from Disconnected,actually sounding like a throwaway from that disc. When FWX showed on my doorstep,I was not as eager as I could have been...then BAM!!! the disc kicked my ass. Almost 2 years later it is still in the number one spot in my 110 disc changer,as the most played disc I own.
Don't count out Evergrey...I expect another classic
 
Thanks for the info Glenn. Although, as another EG fanboy, I'd have bought the album anyways, even though I had my doubts. But it is reassuring to get an idea of how all the songs are (in their entirety), and not just those 3 song clips, that I heard.
 
TwizstedJesus said:
Evergrey releasing a sub-par disc? Not fucking likely! I too heard the clips and did not reserve judgement,because they never fail to kick you in the nuts when the disc comes out.
Remember the sample from Fates Warnings last? "Simple Human" was by far the worst track they could have let out. It showed us no growth from Disconnected,actually sounding like a throwaway from that disc. When FWX showed on my doorstep,I was not as eager as I could have been...then BAM!!! the disc kicked my ass. Almost 2 years later it is still in the number one spot in my 110 disc changer,as the most played disc I own.
Don't count out Evergrey...I expect another classic
That's a very good point. I've noticed that the opinion you can form from a partial or first listen can sometimes differ from the opinion that you'll have after a whole listen or repeated listenings. Some things have to grow on you and you have to give them a fair chance. Besides, they wouldn't pull a "St. Anger" on us! :loco:
 
TwizstedJesus said:
Evergrey releasing a sub-par disc? Not fucking likely!
Reread what I said. My exact words, in reference to the last two CDs was, "Were they very good discs? Yes."

TwizstedJesus said:
I too heard the clips and did not reserve judgement...
TwizstedJesus said:
Remember the sample from Fates Warnings last? "Simple Human" was by far the worst track they could have let out. ...then BAM!!! the disc kicked my ass.
Don't these two statements contradict? On the one hand, you've said that you learned your lesson with Fates Warning. Yet you've also said, that you're not going to withhold judgement on the Evergrey disc and that you've already decided it will "kick your nuts off", based on three samples.

TwizstedJesus said:
Don't count out Evergrey...I expect another classic
Whose counting them out? I said I was going to buy the CD?

Zod
 
l like the clips. The sound is a bit different than EG's previous material, but that in itself can be a plus. I remember when Eldritch did the same thing with their Reverse release. It was somewhat drastically different from their other material, but it kicked my azz. It was like they had stepped out of the studio, took a breath of fresh air, went back in & said "fuck it" and proceeded to lay down material that would head them in a different direction. Sometimes that can be good...sometimes not so good...but in my opinion, not such a bad thing for any band.
Seems to me EG is progressing...isn't that why it's called "progressive" metal?