they are not a very innovative band. It's really been the same formula and idea since it started.
I have have to ask my self what is the greatest power metal album of all time. For me it would be a toss up between Helloween's Keepers 1 & 2. Therefore my answer would be Kiske/hansen era Helloween.
Gamma Ray and Edguy picked up the tourch and carried it but I am not sure that either has done anything that is as good as The Keepers 1 & 2. Close but not equal.
Helloween did have Chamelon and Pink Bubbles
Yeah rightttttttt! Have you heard the pop on their latest? I don't think you can consider the greatest to have music like that amongst their collection, my opinion. I much prefer Iced Earth, Brainstorm, Symphorce, Kamelot, Angra type power metal to those that you listed...
Bear
I'm sorry, I keep seeing this thread and thinking it says, "Gamma Ray GAYEST power metal ever????"
Not that there's anything wrong with that.
-Metal
(To make myself clear: I'm laughing at the title of the thread, not making fun of anyone and their prefrences nor the band itself.)