Hello everyone!
- Thread starter Signify
- Start date
Metal head87
Member
- Jul 17, 2006
- 4,423
- 28
- 48
You and a few other people here bashed Celtic Frost! The new Maiden album didn't get the response it deserved here either. That album is a masterpiece and only a couple of people here said good things about it.Elyia said:lets see how fast your green button turns to red now
They played the whole album live and it was amazing.
Steven Wilson with Opeth> Porcupine Tree
By the way, I don't think I welcomed the new guy yet. Welcome to the site.
Elyia
Member
- Jun 28, 2006
- 240
- 6
- 18
Metal head87 said:
wowowow, slowly dude... i didn't bash Celtic Frost, learn to read.
Maiden album? Have i missed the thread "What do Orphaned Land fans think of the new Iron Maiden?" Did anyone here say "Oh, the new Iron maiden sucks" (By the way, it is a great album... ) And anyway, how does this fit into this thread? Completely offtopic!
If you want appreciation for Maiden, go to the maiden forum, same with celtic....but HERE it is about ORPHANED LAND, in case you forgot.
Anyone who wants to discuss other bands is greatly welcome to the other forums.
Morticia NL.
Orphaned sister
I am not a big PT fan either. I figured I still need to do some more listening to their stuff- sometimes it is just not the right moment to hear something new and than a couple of months later you do like it.
Metal head87
Member
- Jul 17, 2006
- 4,423
- 28
- 48
There was a topic for the new Maiden, although I don't see it now, but everyone was bashing it. I didn't say that you did though.Elyia said:
I thought you were bashing CF. My bad I guess.
Honestly, I never saw why people love Porcupine Tree so much. Same thing with Tool. But to each his own I guess. I'd much rather listen to Rush or Pink Floyd for my softer prog.
Anyway, didn't mean to go off topic.
RashomoN
Eran
Morticia NL.
Orphaned sister
GRAAA- Pink Floyd! Am I the only person on this planet that can't stand this bands music??
Rush I think are utterly boring.
NOW I'll get a red dot for sure
Rush I think are utterly boring.
NOW I'll get a red dot for sure
Pink Floyd, Rush, Tool, all are great bands! you really should give them a second chance.
Aenima by tool is really a work of art, But its not easy to get into.
Same with pink floyd.
And for rush.... well, mostly, only people who like prog will really love them, its not a band for everyone.
Aenima by tool is really a work of art, But its not easy to get into.
Same with pink floyd.
And for rush.... well, mostly, only people who like prog will really love them, its not a band for everyone.
paradoxile
Den Sista Ljusbäraren
most studio albums after the wall are pretty shitty comparing to their previous releases. I can also understand not being attracted to the early psychodelic stuff with Syd Barrett RIP but most of their stuff is epic!Morticia NL. said:GRAAA- Pink Floyd! Am I the only person on this planet that can't stand this bands music??
Rush I think are utterly boring.
NOW I'll get a red dot for sure
Metal head87
Member
- Jul 17, 2006
- 4,423
- 28
- 48
Honestly, I never found Tool's music to really be all that challenging. Same thing with Porcupine Tree. I've tried to get into both since Mikael Akerfeldt is a god and he loves both bands, but I wasn't really drawn into either band at all. No offense to their fans.
Rush are basically for prog fans as Signify has said. I heard their music and I was definitely able to see where Dream Theater came from. Then I really started to get into them. 2112 is essential for all proggers!
I didn't used to like Pink Floyd either. Being an Enslaved addict got me into them.
Rush are basically for prog fans as Signify has said. I heard their music and I was definitely able to see where Dream Theater came from. Then I really started to get into them. 2112 is essential for all proggers!
I didn't used to like Pink Floyd either. Being an Enslaved addict got me into them.
Elyia
Member
- Jun 28, 2006
- 240
- 6
- 18
paradoxile said:Well Signify...you never did tell us your name or where you study
and for that I hate you with all my guts...
but since you like Porcupine Tree(I spoke with Steven Wilson,who wants to fucking touch me?) and Orphaned Land...I'll forgive you
http://www.ultimatemetal.com/forum/showpost.php?p=4762938&postcount=36
I see you quote yourself quite often
Chastise
Platypus.
Well I never tried Porcupine Tree before but I can say that Tool's music is divine imho. I love MJK's voice and King Crimson
in_absentia
Aurora Borealis
PinkThrone
Member
Morticia NL.
Orphaned sister
I love a Perfect Circle though and Uri playes me some Tool- and he almost managed to convince me. I really need to listen to some of that Laterus stuff, sounded pretty cool.
Chastise
Platypus.
Try Ænima first imho. I love Lateralus but the coolest songs of tool (imho) are in Ænima. Like H.,Forty six&2,Third Eye etc.
Metal head87
Member
- Jul 17, 2006
- 4,423
- 28
- 48
I still think Tool is very overrated. I don't think their music is complex really.
If you want really complex prog without keyboards, check out Watchtower.
If you want really complex prog without keyboards, check out Watchtower.
PinkThrone
Member
Metal head87
Member
- Jul 17, 2006
- 4,423
- 28
- 48
PinkThrone
Member
No, that's wrong. Prog is a progression in the music. And they are somewhat progressive, as the drums are complex. The thing that's complex in Tool is the rhytmn, not the guitar scales. But I still wouldn't call them prog., I would call them stoner rock, actually, since they sound alot like bands in the stoner rock category.
