Help decide the tone to use on my record! (Axe Fx II vs POD HD content)

[Dans]

Hey guys, so basically I put this comparison together after months of tweaking and experimenting on my POD HD and the Axe Fx II I'm babysitting for my friend.
This is by no mean a comparison between any specific amp/cab model. These are just the best high-gain patches I got out of both units and I can't decide which one to use on my upcoming EP.
All parameters on both patches are independent and nothing's matched. I like both tones for different reasons so help me decide!
Not gonna tell which tone is which for now but I guess it's rather obvious lol.
Any comment or suggestion is appreciated!

 

[ATLA]

The first tone has much more low end, it suits the material better. That being said i think the second one would sound cool as an affect, ex: solo'd guitars with some kind of phaser/flanger.

 

[inertia]

I like the 2nd tone tone best.

 

[Daybreak]

I'm voting for the first because it kind if sounds deeper and more "controlled" than the second one. Just my two cents!

 

[Dans]

Thanks for the feedback so far guys! Appreciate it

 

[nezvers]

First one has better note definition.
Second one could be POD, because I have HD500x and it sound familiar (I think it could sound better). If I'm mistaken POD HD for AXE-fx, than I'd be surprised in good way.

 

[Winston Wolf]

Too much gain on both. I like the 2 better.