Lars or Benante

[MetalThrasher442]

ok well lars or charlie benante ima go with charlie because i mean i liek anthrax more than metallica and i mean ive just learned so much from charlie and i didnt feel like starting a pole so lets just discuss this what r your thoughts

 

[Brentney Spears]

Charlie can keep time

 

[DeathsHead]

Charlie likes Napster

 

[Gibba]

Charlie don't surf.

 

[ZTPioneer]

Even though I don't like this reunion, Charlie is the best drummer in the world. Period. If I catch a reunion show, it will be to see Chas in action. Oh, and to heckle Blowey Primadonna!
Oh well, maybe they will play "Now It's Dark!" That might make me happy.

 

[sufferer]

Not even in the same league. Charlie smokes that little bitch.

 

[The God of Hellfire]

in the early to mid eighties it was close. but then after and justice, lars plateaued and then started to fall off unitil now where he is little more than a glorified punk rocker. (I still like metallica but i think they need to be playing to their full talent in whatever style they play and in my opinion lars and kirk don't do much on st anger) and then we have charlie who's continued to get better with every album. his stuff on WCFYA is like nothing else.

 

[Silent_Scream]

Fucking hell

Lars is one of the worst most overated drummers ever.

Charlie is one of the best metal drummers ever.

As said before they arent in the same league

 

[The God of Hellfire]

if you want to compare metallica and anthrax how about better rhythm guitarists, hetfield or ian?

 

[DeathsHead]

if you want to compare metallica and anthrax how about better rhythm guitarists, hetfield or ian

Two different styles of playing, both fast, both write excelent riffs but different

 

[johnnieCzech]

Lars is "a good drummer" in his prime, can´t be compared to Charlie, both are sellouts.

 

[timmyc]

Lars is "a good drummer" in his prime, can´t be compared to Charlie, both are sellouts.

No offence Johnnie, but your constant bashing of Anthrax lately is getting pretty tired and boring. If you hate them so much, then why keep posting here?

 

[MRJUCY]

Lars is only fairly ordinary Charlie is one of the very best what do you reckon

 

[The God of Hellfire]

lars used to be really good but now he's more the CEO of metallica than the drummer

 

[johnnieCzech]

No offence Johnnie, but your constant bashing of Anthrax lately is getting pretty tired and boring. If you hate them so much, then why keep posting here?

if you think I hate Anthrax you´re 100% wrong.

 

[Sir Phobos]

I have to agree

others cant top charlie isnt there an S.O.D. song that simply mentions how fast he is . I think it was on "Bigger then the devil" Personally though

I think he kicks ass

 

[stomp224]

I like both equally. Charlies drums fit the songs cos he writes em, and i love how lars follows the guitar lines. I even liked St Anger. I love how hard it is to listen to. Fuck easy listening metal, metal is supposed to be confrontational and you cant get more confrontational than those drum sounds!

 

[DarbysDad]

Charlie - no contest.

 

[lokey]

charlie.... dont cheat

 

[stomp224]

are you referring to the use of pro tools on st anger?