Murphy's Irish Stout Better Than Guinness?

[mick thompson]

well im irish so i guess i'll throw in my say, guinness is much nicer, much creamier, leaves your poop black as fuck and was made pretty darn close to my house in ireland so i vote guinness

 

[spioraid]

Guess my vote.

Murphy's is still good though. Been looking to find their Millennium Brew for a while now but I can't find it anywhere.

 

[Uladyne]

Hmm.. I'm still undecided on this. Given that I live on pretty much the other side of the planet from where both beers are brewed, I'm sure my samples are a bit less than fresh by the time they reach me, pasteurized or not.

I have to admit I'm more of an IPA kind of guy, so I might not be the best judge of Stouts, but so far even after having a pint of Guinness from the tap at a local "Irish" pub (In Newport, Oregon, U.S.A., mind you), I think the cans (!) of Murphy's were a bit more impressive to me. Seemed to have a bit more flavor. Further testing is in order.

 

[MT01]

Nigerian Guinness FTW!!!!111

 

[Dylan S]

I have never tried the Murphy's one but I do like Guiness A LOT.

I'm a big fan of Kilkenny too.

 

[ConspiracyBass]

Give me a Beamish. Fuck Guiness (even though I do like it, haha).

 

[kaomao]

I think it very well may be so. Not sure though. Drunk. Thoughts?

are you kidding? murphy is total crap compared to guinness

 

[kaomao]

Thats true..You'd pay close to 6 euro for a pint in some places,while out in the sticks you'd get one for like 3.50 or so!!!

6 euros is not expensive lol
here 3.5 is the half pint.

 

[ronnan]

6 euros is not expensive lol
here 3.5 is the half pint.

Really??wow,i thought we had it bad...haha..im just a cheap bastard when it comes to beer

 

[Daggorath]

Guiness in Ireland > Murphys > Guiness over here. QFT

 

[J the TyranT]

Belhaven rapes their asses. Regardless, both are overrated.

Belgians eat waffles, then brew better beers.