Haha, laugh if you want, but TTAOE I like the best.  Most influential or revered obviously is BME, but I don't dig it as much, but I still like it.  IMO, the thing MH really has on each album is a KILLER opening track, and the rest of the stuff is pretty good, but not as good as the opening song.  I think their best songs from each album are the opening tracks, from BME all the way up.