Once and for all!!!!

[johnnieCzech]

One thing lurch70: I've been an Anthrax fan since 1988/1989. When Joey was fired, I was really frustrated because I loved his singing. I didn't believe that his successor will be better - John Bush has proved it. It's paradoxical that now, when is Joey Belladonna back, I'm frustrated again...

I vote for JOHN BUSH.

woooow, welcome back, we shall drink beer anytime REAL soon.

 

[aliasp]

Actually I have seen both Bush and Belladonna live and I have to say JOHN stole the show for me he was awesome! Joey was great but John held us in the palm of his hands. He really connected with us! Fuck he even took on a over zealous bouncer who was beating up on the crowd!

 

[Deege]

Gee, it's obvious who's winning this one.

Smart decision.

 

[Deege]

...

 

[Silent_Scream]

Belladonna by a country mile , Bella Anthrax is 1 of my favourite bands and i consider all their albums classics and are each one up their at the top of my favourites with Sound Of White Noise which is brilliant also , Bush sounds magnificent, Anthrax just changed their sound in my opinion to something i dont like as much anymore.

 

[PJ175]

The Voters Dont Lie!!!!

 

[bellyofthebeast20]

joey...john bush doesnt sing well joey era stuff

 

[antwax]

hmmm I listened Music of Mass Destruction today and got a real kick out of it...a boost of energy. Then I put Live...The Islands Years on...and I became sad. I didn't like that "live" album when it was released and today it sounded really very weak, especially after MOMD.
Reunion might be something that Scott and Charlie had to do in order to get Frankie back, but...I don't know - have there been good reunions? NO...even Judas Priest failed to deliver a great album....I think natural progress - John and Rob are that - gives the best results in everything...We've Come For You All is one hell of a album - one of the best! ...And Music Of Mass Destruction IS one of the best live albums ever. It might even better than Deep Purple's Made in Japan!

Antwax

 

[antwax]

"joey...john bush doesnt sing well joey era stuff"

I bet Joey won't sing John era stuff at all...think about that! It's like with Black Sabbath - after reunion all the great albums from Heaven And Hell onwards do not exist...Ozzy did not sing on those so why bother to play anything from them...

I'm not sure if Joey could sing John's songs...Ozzy sure couldn't sing any Dio or Martin stuff.

Antwax

 

[Mr Chuff]

Ok... I'm new. Dont hate me for it...
I joined up for reasons other than the reunion.

I thought i'd throw my hat in the ring and say that I've been a fan since 1987. The Joey era was great. He left, I didnt think they'd recover, I was unsure about Bush but I can't see Anthrax without him now. Now I'm unsure about Joey...

There.... no bitching. Just facts...

 

[GregadetH]

Mr. Chuff gets my vote for 'best post by a noob' ----- ev-ar!

 

[Wrath Inc.]

Belladonna no question. The two best albums had his voice.


Among & Presistence

 

[Deege]

Yup but the worst parts of those two albums were his voice.

 

[johnnieCzech]

Yup but the worst parts of those two albums were his voice.

Indeed. He did his best work on Spreading, then it went downhill.

 

[Schurl]

IMO Joey did best on Persistence of Time and Milk on Killer B´s.