Poll: Worst Metallica Album Of Alltime

[Deadly Embrace]

I saw this thread on the Old School Board.......................so vote your heart, since Metallica sold it's soul...............

 

[Lies and Perfidy]

Load, but Metallica are still my favorite band. The first five (and Live Shit) are just THAT good.

 

[hiddenlegions]

I voted Load. It's even worse than the Black Album...

 

[SoulVomitor]

S&M makes me uke:

 

[Valofvalhalla]

S&M. I think that the symphony work on the black album was excellent. S&M pushed it just a tab too far.

I still bleed Metallica!

 

[HUNGER OF THE UNDEAD]

I am voting for the Black album because it is the one that started the sellout, corporate cock sucking band that has ever since been mCtallica.
It was also the absolute worst concert Ive ever had the misfortune of attending

 

[a guy...]

Voted can't vote....though I occaisionally play some old Metallica re-living those past glories.

 

[stefan86]

Reload is defenitely the worst Metallica album...full of childish mtv songs like fuel and the memory remains uke:

 

[TheBigJones47]

voted ReLoad, i like it but not really a metal album, and their weakest release... up until this forthcoming tour, I have been the most diehard metallica fan... yeah, they changed the music, but what the hell, they're experimenting, got tired of the same old shit, etc., no biggie, they're still metallica.


then they tour with linkin park and soggy muffin? wtf, nobody in their right mind would support a move of such monumental dissapointment, it made me sick for like 4 days after i heard this news... unbelievable, really. oh well, they didn't ask me, obviously.

 

[Ultimate_Symphony]

Reload easily.

 

[Spirit In Black]

From the Black Album on they were a whole different band, and that band sucked. So I voted for can't vote.

 

[Eternal_Decadent]

From Load to S&M (excluding Damage Inc.)

 

[HUNGER OF THE UNDEAD]

yeah, they changed the music, but what the hell, they're experimenting, got tired of the same old shit, etc., no biggie, they're still metallica.

Are you for real?? They havent BEEN Metallica since the Justice tour ended. Everything since then has been a complete fucking disgrace. Those sellout homos should be hung drawn and quartered!

 

[Lies and Perfidy]

Love those intelligent, penetrating, critical arguments. "Sellout homos" indeed...like Rob Halford, perhaps?

 

[Lane]

Reload. Easily... One listen proves that!

 

[phodg]

Voted for "can't vote". Everything after "Justice" is radio-friendly easy rock in my opinion.

 

[Valofvalhalla]

voted ReLoad, i like it but not really a metal album, and their weakest release... up until this forthcoming tour, I have been the most diehard metallica fan... yeah, they changed the music, but what the hell, they're experimenting, got tired of the same old shit, etc., no biggie, they're still metallica.

Wow! You are one of only a few that shows no lack of intellegence when it comes to airing a positive response. I say positive because I basically fee how you posted. It is simply a matter of opinion and taste and I am not knocking what every Testament fan in here writes. Although I will admit that I don't really like it when people say they sold out etc.....which in some cases may be true.

 

[Dirt Junior]

AND JUSTICE FOR ALL WAS THE METAL CD THAT GOT ME INTO METAL!!!!!

THEN THE BLACK CD CAME OUT..WE ALL LAUGHED..THEN LOAD CAME OUT..WE LAUGHED HARDER....NOW WE DON'T CARE WHEN A METALLICA CD COMES OUT!!!

SNM SUCKS THE MOST!!!!! :zombie:

 

[Valofvalhalla]

AND JUSTICE FOR ALL WAS THE METAL CD THAT GOT ME INTO METAL!!!!!

I will agree, but it wasn't Justice for me.

THEN THE BLACK CD CAME OUT..WE ALL LAUGHED..THEN LOAD CAME OUT..WE LAUGHED HARDER....NOW WE DON'T CARE WHEN A METALLICA CD COMES OUT!!!

We? Are you speaking for everyone in here? Just a little note, if you take the time to read previous threads, you will see that there are several people in this forum that don't agree with the above-mentioned post. Certainly, I don't want to be counted in your "WE". (And I post this without sarcasm)

SNM SUCKS THE MOST!!!!! :zombie:

And that is definately one thing that I agree with you on!

Rock On Dirt

 

[Zob Rombie]

i didnt get to vote on this poll but i would def. agree that Reload was the worst...im waiting to see whats on Metallica's St. Anger album