I finally updated my totals. A few disclaimers:
Those that listed more than 10 choices (except for either/or cases) were rejected.
Either/or choices were counted as half votes for each band
Any additional lists posted by the same person were ignored for the purposes of this tally.
Apologies if any of my totals are off. I'm doing this for fun, remember!!!
I am not counting pre-party bands at present. I think a separate thread for this might be appropriate...
Without further ado
The Major Favorites (20 or more votes)
Sonata Arctica - 31
Stratovarius - 30
Rhapsody - 27
Helloween - 24.5
Iced Earth - 22
Other Big Favorites (10 or more votes)
Kamelot - 17
Savatage - 17
Adagio - 16
Masterplan - 16
Edguy - 14
Pain Of Salvation - 14
Lost Horizon - 13
Enchant - 12
Labyrinth - 10.5
Andromeda - 10
Running Wild - 10
Additional Favorites (5 or more votes)
Shaman - 8
Blind Guardian - 7.5
Dream Evil - 7.5
Hammerfall - 7.5
Brainstorm - 7
Children Of Bodom - 7
Conception - 7
Fates Warning - 7
Grave Digger - 7
Heavenly - 7(?)
Lacuna Coil - 7
Royal Hunt - 7
Spiral Architect - 7
Nightwish - 6
Nocturnal Rites - 6
Power Of Omens - 6
The Gathering - 6
Virgin Steele - 6
Ayreon - 5.5
After Forever - 5
Angra - 5
Gordian Knot - 5
Evergrey - 5
Nevermore - 5
Opeth - 5
And The Rest...
4-4.5 votes
Agent Steel, Ark (note: if same band as Arc, then 5 votes), Borkagnar, Crimson Glory, Dead Soul Tribe, Demons And Wizards (4.5), Elegy, Freak Kitchen, Into Eternity, Jag Panzer, Metallium, Sentanced, Tad Morose, Therion, Watchtower, Zero Hour
3-3.5 votes
Amaran, At Vance, Cage, Freedom Call, Gamma Ray (3.5), Green Carnation, Human Fortress, Lullacry, Marillion, Spock's Beard, Stonehenge, Threshold, Tierra Santa, Voivod
2-2.5 votes
Amorphis, Anathema, Anecdoten, Bruce Dickinson, Carcass, Dark Tranquility, DGM, Dragonforce, Dreamtale, Edenbridge, Elvenking, John Arch, Lana Lane (2.5), Madder Mortem, Madsword, Manowar, Novembre, Porcupine Tree, Rage, Sinergy, Soilwork, Steel Attack, Stormwitch, Strapping Young Lad, Superior, Symphony X, Tarot, Theocracy, The Lord Weird Slough Feg, Tuatha de Denann, Uli Jon Roth, Vanishing Point, Vintersong, Vision Divine (2.5), Wolverine
1.5 votes or less
Aghora, Am I Blood, Anacrucis, Angel Dust, Annihlator, Apocalyptica, Arc (if not Ark), Archetype, Aria, Artention, Ascension Theory, Athiest, Avantasia, Axel Rudi Pell, Aztec Jade, Balance Of Power, Ballurio, Bal-Sagoth, Battlelore, Blue Oyster Cult, Brave, Brazen Angel, Carcass, Cathedral, Celtic Frost, Chastain, Concerto Moon, Control Denied, Cornerstone, Death Machine, Diamond Head, Dimention, Divinity Destroyed, Dragon Steel, Dragonland, Dragonspoon, Dreamscape, Dream Theater, Engine, Entwine, Epica, Erik Norlander (.5), Exciter, Finntroll, Firewind, Force Of Evil, Gallowglass, Greyhaven, Gun Barrel, Hades, Hammers Of Misfortune, Harem Scarem, Heimdall, Hourglass (2 mentions also), Humanimal (.5), Ivory Tower, Jaguar, Kalmah, Katagory V, Kayo Dot, King Crimson, Lamb Of God, Liquid Tension Experiment, Magistral, Magnitude 9, Mago de Oz, Manticora, Maximum Indifference, Mayadome, Mind's Eye, Miss Mercuria, Montany, Mullmuzzler, My Dying Bride, Mystic Prophecy, Onward, OSI, Pain, Paragon, Pathos, Pendragon, Planet X, Pyramaze, Queensryche, Quidan, Rawhead Rexx, Riot, Ron Thal (.5), Steel Tiger, Sacred Steel, Saxon, Section A, Seven Witches, Seventh One, Shadow, Shadow Gallery, Siges Even, Skyfire, Skylark, Sleepytime Gorilla Museum, Solitude Aeturnus, Spiritual Beggers, Steel Prophet, Thought Industry, Thor's Hammer, Thy Majestie, Thyrane, Time Requiem, TNT, Tomorrow's Eve, Tristania, Tunnelvision, Within Temptation, Wolf, Wuthering Heights