QR and SX in NYC; the Good, the Bad and the Ugly

General Zod

Ruler of Australia
May 1, 2001
14,192
36
48
New Jersey
www.facebook.com
Symphony X

The Good – hey, it’s Symphony X, it’s all good. The highlight of the show was Russell. This was the sixth time I’ve seen SX, and I’d say it was his best performance.

The Bad – they only played five songs; Inferno, Wicked, Awakenings, Communion and The Oracle, and Of Sins and Shadows. Any way you slice it, this is not long enough. I’ve been to hundreds of concerts in my life, and I can’t remember an opening band being limited to a thirty minute set.

The Ugly - the sound guy did a horrible job. At different parts during the show, each of the instruments was too loud in the mix.

Queensryche

The Good – “Operation: Mindcrime”. While this was not performed with the same intensity, passion and flawless execution that it was on the “Building Empires” tour, it was delivered in such a manner as to show why QR is the father of this genre. And I was once again reminded, no CD will ever top “Operation: Mindcrime”.

The Bad – the song selection. Hey, I understand why they need to play songs off “Tribe”. However, why do they need to play the other crap? Is there someone in the audience who would prefer to hear “Hit the Black” over “Walk in the Shadows”? Is there someone in the audience who would prefer to hear “The Best I Can” over “Take Hold of the Flame”? If there is, could someone kindly point them out to me, so that I could drag them outside and kick the crap out of them, so that Queensryche could stop playing these shit songs live?

The Ugly – “Roads to Madness”. When they finally treated us to a bit of classic Ryche, they decide it’s a good idea for 2004 Queensryche to change musically, what the vastly superior 1984 Queensryche did. Please! This is the equivalent of Metallica doing an updated version of “For Whom the Bell Tolls” for "St. Anger".

Two small annoyances.

It annoyed me that QR didn’t have the class to thank their opening band. I’m not sure I’ve ever seen a headliner choose not to thank their support act.

Can QR get a guitar player who isn’t visually distracting? This guy couldn’t have possibly looked more out of place on stage with this band. Granted, a band’s image isn’t all that important. Hell, I love Symphony X, and when they take the stage they look like someone just woke them up and that they’re wearing last night’s clothes.

Zod
 
First of all, read this: http://www.ultimatemetal.com/forum/showthread.php?t=148076

:loco:

General Zod said:
The Ugly - the sound guy did a horrible job. At different parts during the show, each of the instruments was too loud in the mix.


It was atrocious. I felt bad for them, considering they were all on top form.

It annoyed me that QR didn’t have the class to thank their opening band. I’m not sure I’ve ever seen a headliner choose not to thank their support act.


You know, now that you mention it, I don't think I've ever heard a headliner thank an opening act. It didn't even occur to me that Queensryche didn't do this, heh!

Hell, I love Symphony X, and when they take the stage they look like someone just woke them up and that they’re wearing last night’s clothes.
Yeah, they are a unit. I can't imagine any one of them being replaceable.
 
markgugs said:
I have no problems with QR's setlist...
None? Five tracks from "Tribe" and a total of two from the first three releases? They did more songs from "Hear in the New Frontier" than they did "Rage for Order". No problem with that? You weren't bored out of your mind for the better part of the first half of the show?

As for owning the stage, Geoff is a good frontman, albeit not 1/10 what he was back in the day. The rest of the band was wearing cement shoes.

Zod
 
I don't know Mark... we definitely left the Beacon with a different view of what transpired. Queensryche, with the exception of the "Mindcrime" material and the song "Empire", couldn't have been more boring. And having seen "Mindcrime" performed when the band was at its peek, I wasn't overly impressed with their rendering of that material last night either.

To my ear, the "Tribe" material is just flat out dull. It's not even interesting enough for me to search my vocabulary for a more fitting description of it. It sounds like uninspired music, that could have been written by a band with one tenth the talent that wrote their earlier material. Their energy was low. Wilton and Jackson seemed bored. I think Wilton only visited the right side of the stage once. I'd be surprised to learn that he broke a sweat. So to say they blew SX away, based on the reaction of a crowd who never even heard of Queensryche prior to "Silent Lucidity" being put into heavy rotation on MTV, doesn't hold water. I'm just not impressed by an audience that kept crying out to hear "Jet City Woman".

I glad you enjoyed the show, but I would never pay to see them again.

Zod