Sepultura: rank 'em.

[NAD]

Chaos A.D.
Arise
Roots
Beneath the Remains
Against
Nation (only listened to this one once)

I'm just counting proper studio full lengths (even though Blood Rooted is as good as if not better than Roots), and I don't own Schizophrenia or Morbid Visions.

I know a lot of people don't like Roots because it's simplistic (I could care less), but why the hate for Chaos A.D.? Too accessible? Hate Jello Biafra?

 

[J.]

pfftt..Chaos AD ain't nu-metal. That's just dumb.

Chaos AD
Arise
Beneath the Remains
Roots

haven't heard the others.

 

[Krilons Resa]

Beneath The Remains
Morbid Visions
Roots
Chaos A.D.

I think they suck now though.

 

[NAD]

I just realized Roorback was a proper album, I thought it was an EP. Might have to pick that up on half.com just for principle's sake.

 

[J.]

that fat dancing kid scares me

 

[NAD]

You're going to pick up one of the gay albums when you don't have Schizophrenia or Morbid Visions yet?

I'll probably get all three at once, which is why I mentioned half.com.

 

[Krilons Resa]

Oh, I forgot about Schitzophrenia


That kid RULES, J.

 

[NAD]

Yeah it's paired with Morbid Visions now. I'll just pick them all up in one fell swoop in a month or so.

That kid is sad, I hate to see obese children. At least she's having a good time, I guess.

 

[Weapon X]

Ahhh Mainstream Metal, now that is my area

Chaos AD
Arise
Roots
Nation
BTR
Roorback\Revolusongs
Against
Morbid Visions\Bestial Devestations

 

[Carbonized]

Chaos A.D. (saw them on this tour w/Fudge Tunnel, Fear Factory and Clutch)
Arise/Dead Embryonic Cells E.P. (I mention the E.P. because the cover of Orgasmatron just kicks ass)
Beneath the Remains (I like this one a lot as well)
Roots erk: )
Against (Haven't heard this one)
Nation (Nor this one... but damn all that tribal shit got old real fast)

and Soulfly is teh po0p

 

[Black Winter Day]

That kid is sad, I hate to see obese children. At least she's having a good time, I guess.

hahaha, i remember when i posted that same pic a few months ago and you said "that fat girl makes me sad"

 

[Krilons Resa]

Howard The Duck!!!!!

 

[Krilons Resa]

hahaha, i remember when i posted that same pic a few months ago and you said "that fat girl makes me sad"

HAHA

 

[Carbonized]

Howard The Duck!!!!!

lol yes! a film that gets unceremoniously trashed by the critics. i happened to like it very much! i used to be jealous of Howard when he slept with Lea Thompson...

 

[NAD]

Brought up Howard the Duck earlier tonight, why? Because HE KICKS FUCKING ASS!!! ANd Leath Thompssonson assshot was worth swatching teh move 1209873109847 times when I was 8.

 

[Under a Stone]

Hmm...let's see

Beneath the Remains(worthy enough to rival Slayer's Reign in Blood)
Arise
Schizophrenia
Chaos AD
Morbid Visions
Nation
Roorback
Against
Roots

 

[JayKeeley]

How the fuck does Chaos AD get ranked higher than Beneath the Remains??? What are you fucking nuts people?

Beneath the Remains (worthy enough to leave Slayer's Reign in Blood in shattered pieces, and then pissed and puked on before being shat on with lentl soup diarreha)
Arise
Schizophrenia
Morbid Visions & Bestial Devastation (I have the combo CD so I'll give them equal billing)

And then all the stuff once Andreas Kisser became a company overhead...

Chaos AD
Roots
Nation & Against (as good and as bad as each other)

Not heard Roorback.

Bear in mind, just cos Roots is close to the bottom of my list, doesn't mean it still doesn't rule.

Sepultura were, without any doubt in my mind, the greatest brutal thrash in the world before Kisser lost all inspiration and ability. (Let's face it, for as good as Roots and Chaos AD are, you can remove Kisser and still have the same album).

Even to this day, I'll take Sepultura clones just to further my listening pleasure, and I have hunted high & low. I've even posted fucking threads about it, asking for rip-offs, and nobody has ever listed anything that comes close, either in quality or even semblance.

 

[JayKeeley]

Just a little....

*wipes sweat of brow*

 

[Papa Josh]

How the fuck does Chaos AD get ranked higher than Beneath the Remains??? What are you fucking nuts people?

Beneath the Remains (worthy enough to leave Slayer's Reign in Blood in shattered pieces, and then pissed and puked on before being shat on with lentl soup diarreha)
Arise
Schizophrenia
Morbid Visions & Bestial Devastation (I have the combo CD so I'll give them equal billing)

And then all the stuff once Andreas Kisser became a company overhead...

Chaos AD
Roots
Nation & Against (as good and as bad as each other)

Not heard Roorback.

Bear in mind, just cos Roots is close to the bottom of my list, doesn't mean it still doesn't rule.

Sepultura were, without any doubt in my mind, the greatest brutal thrash in the world before Kisser lost all inspiration and ability. (Let's face it, for as good as Roots and Chaos AD are, you can remove Kisser and still have the same album).

Even to this day, I'll take Sepultura clones just to further my listening pleasure, and I have hunted high & low. I've even posted fucking threads about it, asking for rip-offs, and nobody has ever listed anything that comes close, either in quality or even semblance.

While I completely and wholeheartedly agree with your ranking of Beneath The Remains and Arise, I can't say that I draw the same analysis of Andreas Kisser. Max completely took over the band, so of course Kisser's input would be less.

 

[JayKeeley]

Is that right?! Damn!

Oy Max! You fat bastard!