Star Opeth's work

[Hypnos]

My Arms Your Hearse - 2.5/5
...
Blackwater Park Bonus Disc - 6/5

???

 

[Korlich]

Orchid 9/10
Morningrise 7/10
MAYH 8/10
SL 10/10
BWP 7/10
D1 6/10
D2 6/10
GR 7/10

 

[Korlich]

Lamentations 7/10

 

[Nairolf]

^GR?????

 

[narcoleptic haze]

???

What can i say, MAYH just isn't that good. I still like it, but it's certainly my least favourite.

And the two songs on the BWP bonus disc are outstanding. That's why I gave it a 6 out of 5.


.

 

[Oakenpalace]

Orchid - 4/5
Morninigrise - 4.5/5
My Arms Your Hearse - 3.5/5
Still Life - 5/5
Blackwater Park - 5/5
Deliverance - 3.5/5
Damnation - 4/5
Lamentations - 4/5

 

[[KOTNO]Narrot]

Orchid - 3.5/5
Morninigrise - 3/5
My Arms Your Hearse - 5/5
Still Life - 4.5/5
Blackwater Park - 4/5
Deliverance - 4/5
Damnation - 4/5

well, i just don't like the first two records too much (by opeth standards)

 

[n0thing]

Orchid - 3
Morningrise - 3
My Arms Your Hearse - 4.5
Still Life - 4
Blackwater Park - 5
Deliverance - 4
Damnation - 4.5
Lamentations - 5

 

[Rahan]

Orchid - 5 Stars
Morningrise - 5 Stars

My Arms Your Hearse - 4.5 Stars
Still Life - 4.5 Stars
Blackwater Park - 4.5 Stars

Deliverance - 4 Stars
Damnation - 4 Stars
Lamentations - 4 Stars

hemmm ... Looks slightly downhill ...
I hope it's not an indication that Ghost Reveries will be only 3.5 Stars ...

 

[Thonolan]

Orchid - 4,5/5
Morningrise - 4,5/5
My Arms Your Hearse - didn't hear it yet
Still Life - 4/5
Blackwater Park - 5/5
Deliverance - 4,5/5
Damnation - 5/5

 

[Stimuli]

MAYH - 4.5/5
Still Life - 5/5
Blackwater Park - 5/5
Deliverance - 4.5/5
Damnation - 4.5/5
Lamentations - 5.5
TGC - 5/5

 

[CAIRATH]

Orchid 3.5
Morningrise 3.5
My Arms, Your Hearse 5
Still Life 4.5
Blackwater Park 4.5
Deliverance 3.5
Damnation 4
Lamentations 3 (5 minus 2 stars for not including any MAYH or Still Life material to offset the newer stuff)

 

[Animus]

Orchid - 3.5/5
Morninigrise - 4.5/5
My Arms Your Hearse - 4/5
Still Life - 5/5
Blackwater Park - 3/5
Deliverance - 2.5/5
Damnation - 3.5/5

 

[Man In Black]

Orchid - 3/5
Morningrise - 3.5/5
MAYH - 4/5
Still Life - 5/5
Blackwater Park - 5/5
Deliverance - 4/5
Damnation - 4/5
Ghost Reveries - N/A (TGC - 4/5)

 

[Risquit]

Strange, most people like Damnation better than Deliverance.

 

[Kichacid]

Strange, most people like Damnation better than Deliverance.

Yes, this seems to be quite trendy. *is a hypocrite*

 

[Longinus]

Orchid - ****
Morningrise - ****1/2
MAYH - *****
Still Life - *****
Blackwater Park - *****
Deliverance - ****1/2
Damnation - ****
Lamentations - ****
TGC - ****1/2 (that solo!)

 

[forestofmyths]

Orchid 2/5
Morningrise 2/5
My Arms, Your Hearse 3/5
Still Life 4.5/5
Blackwater Park 5/5
Deliverance 4/5
Damnation 5/5
Lamentations 5/5

 

[Alex78]

Orchid: ****
Morningrise: ***
MAYH: *****
SL: ****
BWP: *****
D1: ***
D2: ***

 

[Mistress Bleak]

Orchid - 3.5/5
Morningrise - 3.5/5
MAYH - 4.5/5
Still Life - 1000/5
BWP - 5/5
Deliverance - 4.5/5
Damnation - 4/5
Lamentations - 4.5/5