Hi, guys, mind if I argue a bit?
First of all, let's not exaggerate things. Most of the concurent compression formats are able to achieve transparent compression in not too big bitrates. This means that the compressed files have no artifacts and deliver quite good sound quality. And to really appreciate the difference between original files and compressed ones you need a quite expensive hardware, with 90% of the general public still listening to their home hi-fis or their pc speakers that difference in the textures of the sound is hardly perceptible.
Then, we get to the moral side of things. I agree if you can afford all the albums you listen to, you should buy them. But if you don't? A single original CD here in Bulgaria costs more than my monthly scholarship I receive at school. So, how can I buy all the albums I want to listen to? Shortly - I don't buy them all, I buy one and download the others. Personnaly, I think that music is an art, and nothing should stop me from appreciating it. Also, we might say something about availability. When I heard Cold Light of Monday, I went to all the record stores around here and asked about it. Most of them hadn't even heard of Wolverine to begin with. And those are the stores that are supposed to have all the non-commercial (if I can put it that way) music. There was only one store that had imported ONE copy of the album, and had already sold it. I had to bug two record stores to import another copy, and had to wait about six months, because one of the distributors wasn't serious enough.
Also, mp3s are not the big bad monster you describe. Actually, if it weren't for them, a lot of artists probably wouldn't get that popularity the tend to enjoy now. And I'm not talking about the big fishes in the game, I'm also talking about the guys that are in the beginnings of their careers. Wolverine get more exposure thanks to the internet and mp3s. I'm a proof of this. If I hadn't download CLoM, I wouldn't have bought it. Saying that mp3s are harmfull is only seeing one side of things, and that's not fair.
That's all for now. Hope I'm not offending someone, I just thought that there should be another point of view.
Cheers!
Karamfil
