The *PROPER DOOM* Thread

[cedarbreed]

here we go again :

which ones of those bands do you consider (or still consider )as 'DOOM METAL' , whether they changed their musical orientation or not.
you can give multiple answers

That one may be fun , let's see where are the true Doomsters

Fuck ! I can only give 20 options ! I had a 40 bands list !

 

[Mariner]

proper doom hé? doh i'm not sure about MDB, they have doomlyrics and wankerlyrics...

 

[Mariner]

skepticism
i voted for Anathema gathering sentenced and it picked MDB out as well. Not all MDBlyrics are good though

 

[Neonseed]

Cathedral,Candlemass only.

 

[cedarbreed]

My votes went to :

Shape of Despair
Saturnus
My Dying Bride
Thergothon
Skepticism
Dolorian
Candlemass
Cathedral
Black Sabbath

All the others either never fitted to that *PROPER DOOM* label or just dont fit to it anymore. If you want to vote for a band that played *PROPER FUKING HARIY CHEST MAN DOOM* but doesnt anymore, you're free to do so of course ...

Fuck i wanted to add bands such as : burning witch , eyehategod , crowbar , st vitus , sleep , iron monkey ... NOT ENOUGH OPTIONS

 

[Cerulean]

[WHINING] Hey this suck
Half of your list is not doom metal!
The Gathering?? I hope you're talking about the Bart Smits era, that was ace doomdeath yes. OPETH!!?? Gimme a break Lacuna Coil? Doom? In The Woods??? Yeas sure it's ace, but it's not dooooom. HIM!!???? You must be kidding me Entwine?
Who's the poser now eh [/WHINING]

 

[Mariner]

you dont have a clue about PROPER doom neonseed
and gorik

Jewel is more doom by example then Skepticism

 

[cedarbreed]

now i can go weeping and mourning the loss of my beloveth in the forest by the graveyard ( i gotta check if it's fullmoon before )

goodnight you all

stay DOOM

 

[cedarbreed]

Originally posted by Cerulean
[WHINING] Hey this suck
Half of your list is not doom metal!
The Gathering?? I hope you're talking about the Bart Smits era, that was ace doomdeath yes. OPETH!!?? Gimme a break Lacuna Coil? Doom? In The Woods??? Yeas sure it's ace, but it's not dooooom. HIM!!???? You must be kidding me Entwine?
Who's the poser now eh [/WHINING]

I EXPECTED THAT VERY KIND OF COMMENTS GORIK

 

[Cerulean]

The proper doom we should be talking about (in my humble opinion!!!!) is old Anathema, My Dying Bride, old Katatonia, old Paradise Lost, Saturnus, old The Gathering, diSEMBOWELMENT, Funeral, Morgion, and some much more others

 

[Neonseed]

Originally posted by Mariner
you dont have a clue about PROPER doom neonseed
and gorik

Jewel is more doom by example then Skepticism

He says doom metal mariner not proper doom. read the post.

 

[Cerulean]

Originally posted by cedarbreed
I EXPECTED THAT VERY KIND OF COMMENTS GORIK

 

[cedarbreed]

yeah i wanted to add morgion ; katatonia ... i told you ... not enough options !

 

[cedarbreed]

Originally posted by Mariner
you dont have a clue about PROPER doom neonseed
and gorik

[/QUOTE

I think he's right on the contrary !
A little restrictive but right ! Candlemass and Cathedral are proper doom IMO

Anyway what's proper doom ??? and what's the difference between proper doom et doom metal ... fuck i'm stoned again ...

OOOooooopppppPPPPPiiiiiiIIIIIIIuuuuuUUUUmmmmmmMMMMM ...

Hell yeh i forgot Moonspell !!!

 

[Mariner]

Originally posted by Neonseed
He says doom metal mariner not proper doom. read the post.

the thread and the poll are saying proper doom
the post is saying doommetal!
hey fucking french dude, thats not done properly!

 

[Mariner]

Moonspell is proper doom, not all of them songs, but the half of it are

 

[Cerulean]

Proper doom=lyrics about real life, real problems maybe...
Real doom metal is TUUUURN LOOOOSE THE SWAAAAAAAAAAANS

 

[Neonseed]

All this bands were/are for one or more albums DOOM METAL!
3rd And The Mortal, The

Aarni
Abdullah
Abysmal Grief
Acrimony
Akilles
Amorphis
Anathema
Aphotic
As Divine Grace
Aseidad
Ashen Mortality
Ashes You Leave
Asmodæo
Autumnal
Avernus
Averon
Avrigus

Bedemon
Before the rain
Bellator
Bells of Doom
Bethlehem
Beyond Dawn
Bitterdusk
Black Lodge
Black Manta
Black Sabbath
Blueprint Human Being
Blood Divine, The
Blood Farmers
Blood Legacy
Blood Tears
Burning Witch

Candlemass
Cantar
Cast in Stone
Castle
Cathedral
Celestial Season
Cemetery of Scream
Ceremonium
Chain, Paul / Death SS
Chalice
Church of Misery
Circle of Nero
Cold Embrace
Cold Mourning
Confessor
Count Raven
Crestfallen (ger)
Crowbar
Cruevo
Cryptal Darkness
Cultus Sanguine

Daedeloth
Dawn of Winter
Death Row
Deinonychus
Desire
Despond
Devout
diSEMBOWELMENT
Dissolving of Prodigy
Divine Silence
Dolorian
Doomenicus
Doomsday Ceremony
Dot(.)
Draconian
Dragonauta
Dream Death
Dreaming
Dusk
Dying Passion

Earth
Earthcorpse
Electric Wizard
Eleventh Room, the
Empyrium
Enchantment
Eria d'Or
Esoteric
Estatic Fear
Even Vast
Evoken
Eyehategod
Eyes of Ligeia

Fall of Empyrean
Fall of the grey winged one
Foetor
Forest of Shadows
Forever Autumn
Forlorn (swe)
Forsaken
Forty Days Longing
Funeral
Funereum

Galadriel
Gardens of Gehenna
Gathering, The
Goat Horn
Goatsnake
Godeatgod
Godsend
Golgotha
Goresleeps
Grave Flowers
Green Carnation
Grief

Hierophant
High On Fire
Hlidolf

Insanity Reigns Supreme
Internal Void
Iron Man

Jack Frost

Katatonia
Khanate
Knell, The

Lacrimas Profundere
Lake of Tears
Lapsus Dei
Las Cruces
Last Chapter
Left Hand Solution
Life Beyond
Long Winters Stare
Lords Of The Stone
Lycanthia

Madder Mortem
Mael Mórdha
Malasangre
Mar de grises
Memento Mori
Memory Garden
Mindrot
Mistralth
Mirror of Deception
Morgion
Morphia
Mourn
Mournful Congregation
Mourning Beloveth
Mül
My Dying Bride
My Shameful
Mystic Charm
Mythic
Mythological Cold Towers

Necare
Negative Theory
Nemesis
Nightly Gale
Ningizzia
Niobes Ivory Dream
Northwinds
Novembers Doom
Nyarlathotep

Obsessed, The
October Tide
Officium Triste
Orbital Doom
Orodruin
Oversoul

Pagan Altar
Pantheïst
Paradigma
Paradise Lost
Paramaecium
Pelican
Penance
Pentagram
Place of Skulls
Pod People
Poema Arcanus
Prior's Diary, the
Prophecy, the
Purgation
Pyogenesis

Rain Paint
Ras Algethi
Revelation
Reverend Bizarre
Rusty Souls

Saint Vitus
Saturnus
Semlah
Serenades
Serenity
Serpent
Shape of Despair
She Cries
Silentium
Skepticism
Sleep
Sloth
Slow Horse
Solace
Solitude Aeturnus
Solstice
Southern Cross
Spancer
Spirit Caravan
Spiritual Dissolvent
Spiritus Mortis
Stone Wings
Substance for God
Subversion
Sunn O)))

Teeth of Lions Rule the ..
Tefra
Thee Plague of Gentlemen
Theatre of Tragedy
Thergothon
This Tangled Web
Thorns of the Carrion
Thorr's Hammer
Thunderstorm
Tiamat
Tristitia
Trouble

Umbra Nihil
Unearthly Trance
Unholy
Unorthodox
Unsilence
Until death overtakes me

Violet Vortex
Visceral Evisceration
Voodoo Shock

Warhorse
Warning
We, the Gods
While Heaven Wept
Whispering Forest
Winter
Witchfinder General
Witch Mountain
Withering Spring
Worship
Within Tears
Wretched
Wytchcraft

Yearning
Yob

Zafira
Zaraza

 

[cedarbreed]

Originally posted by Mariner
the thread and the poll are saying proper doom
the post is saying doommetal!
hey fucking french dude, thats not done properly!

Yeah i took some pills again ... sorry ... let's say its about PROPER DOOM ! RIGHT ?

 

[Cerulean]

What was the point of that eh :Smug: