Ultimate Metal Band Game

[BreathingShadow]

if you are bored, play this game its fun.

The rules are, we start with a selection of bands, all have 10pts. Every member of the forum is entilted to 2 possitive and 2 negative points a day. These points are used to up your favourite band on the list, and down your least favourite band.

The next person continues from where the previous person left off. When a band gets to 0 it is removed from the list and the game continues until only one band is left standing... that band is the ultimate band.

no opeth obviously cause they would win


10- Arcturus
10- Borknagar
09- Ayreon (-1)
10- Bathory
10- Agalloch
10- Dan Swano's Moontower
09- Devin Townsend Band (-1)
10- Edge of Sanity
10- Disillusion
10- Ensiferum
11- Nightingale (+1)
11- Moonsorrow (+1)
10- Porcupine Tree
10- Solefald
10- Vintersorg

 

[MasterOLightning]

Ayreon -2
Agalloch +2

Really odd selection of bands, but whatever. Way heavy on prog and viking bands, and no death metal.

 

[all_sins_undone]

Edge of Sanity +2
Ayreon -2

 

[BreathingShadow]

copy and paste my list so people know the points each band has

 

[The Evil Toucan]

No Ulver? You aren't even gonna get people to agree on teh bands to begin with.

Devin Townsend Band +1
Porcupine Tree +1
Moontower -1
Nightingale -1

 

[BreathingShadow]

10- Arcturus
10- Borknagar
05- Ayreon
10- Bathory
12- Agalloch
10- Dan Swano's Moontower
09- Devin Townsend Band
12- Edge of Sanity
10- Disillusion
10- Ensiferum
11- Nightingale
11- Moonsorrow
10- Porcupine Tree
10- Solefald
10- Vintersorg

 

[Black Paragon]

+2 Porcupine tree

 

[BreathingShadow]

copy the whole list everytime so we know what the bands points are and what they end up on when you are "adding 2"

 

[Alcapoth]

+1 Arcturus
+1 Porcupine Tree

-1 Devin Townsend Band
-1 Vintersorg


more than half the bands I haven't even heard on this list....

 

[daz436]

+2 Porcupine Tree

and ive only ever heard of 2 of those bands

 

[all_sins_undone]

COPY AND FUCKING PASTE THE LIST DUMBASSES

 

[Smoof]

+1 Ensiferum
+1 Devin Townsend Band
-2 Bathory

Taken from post 6 above, updated with all posts after.

11- Arcturus
10- Borknagar
05- Ayreon
08- Bathory
12- Agalloch
10- Dan Swano's Moontower
09- Devin Townsend Band
12- Edge of Sanity
10- Disillusion
11- Ensiferum
11- Nightingale
11- Moonsorrow
15- Porcupine Tree
10- Solefald
09- Vintersorg

 

[alienuth]

as accurate as i can figure.
porcupine tree +2
devin townsend band -2

11- Arcturus
10- Borknagar
05- Ayreon
08- Bathory
12- Agalloch
9- Dan Swano's Moontower
8- Devin Townsend Band
12- Edge of Sanity
10- Disillusion
11- Ensiferum
10- Nightingale
11- Moonsorrow
18- Porcupine Tree
10- Solefald
9- Vintersorg

 

[Braighs]

+2 VIntersorg
-1 Porc Tree So many good bands
-1 Moontower

11- Arcturus
10- Borknagar
05- Ayreon
08- Bathory
12- Agalloch
8- Dan Swano's Moontower
8- Devin Townsend Band
12- Edge of Sanity
10- Disillusion
11- Ensiferum
10- Nightingale
11- Moonsorrow
17- Porcupine Tree
10- Solefald
11- Vintersorg

 

[EternalMetal]

Devin Townsend Band +2
Porcupine Tree -2 (everyone likes them, lets knock them down off their high horse )

11- Arcturus
10- Borknagar
05- Ayreon
08- Bathory
12- Agalloch
8- Dan Swano's Moontower
10- Devin Townsend Band
12- Edge of Sanity
10- Disillusion
11- Ensiferum
10- Nightingale
11- Moonsorrow
15- Porcupine Tree
10- Solefald
11- Vintersorg

 

[BreathingShadow]

Really odd selection of bands, but whatever. Way heavy on prog and viking bands, and no death metal.

sorry i wasnt trying to go by any theme, i just picked the bands that i thought of first

 

[bloodlust rampant]

+2 Bathory
-1 Arcturus
-1 Ayreon

10- Arcturus
10- Borknagar
04- Ayreon
10- Bathory
12- Agalloch
8- Dan Swano's Moontower
10- Devin Townsend Band
12- Edge of Sanity
10- Disillusion
11- Ensiferum
10- Nightingale
11- Moonsorrow
15- Porcupine Tree
10- Solefald
11- Vintersorg

 

[Satyros]

Borknagar+
Porcupine Tree+

Devin Townsend Band -
Bathory-

 

[all_sins_undone]

COPY AND PASTE DUMBASS

 

[NFU]

man, this is the worst "game" ever. only a couple of those bands are worthy to be in an "ultimate" anything context...and porcupine tree isnt even a "metal" band to begin with. Get rid of the homoerotic stuff, and put some bands people can actually agree on maybe. oh wait, i forgot which forum im on. carry on.