Ultimate Metal Band Game

[Braighs]

Vintersorg +2
Porc Tree -2 (shouldn't be here)

=

14- Arcturus
12- Borknagar
16- Agalloch
10- Dan Swanö's Moontower
12- Devin Townsend Band
18- Edge of Sanity
14- Disillusion
12- Nightingale
11- Moonsorrow
08- Porcupine Tree
08- Solefald
17- Vintersorg

 

[Kenneth R.]

Porc Tree -2 (shouldn't be here)

thank you

 

[alienuth]

porcupine tree +2
devin townsend band -2

14- Arcturus
12- Borknagar
16- Agalloch
10- Dan Swanö's Moontower
10- Devin Townsend Band
18- Edge of Sanity
14- Disillusion
12- Nightingale
11- Moonsorrow
10- Porcupine Tree
08- Solefald
17- Vintersorg

 

[apostle]

Porcupine tree +2
Solefald -2


14- Arcturus
12- Borknagar
16- Agalloch
10- Dan Swanö's Moontower
10- Devin Townsend Band
18- Edge of Sanity
14- Disillusion
12- Nightingale
11- Moonsorrow
12- Porcupine Tree
06- Solefald
17- Vintersorg

 

[Black Rain]

Arcturus + 2
Disillusion -2 (I think they suck, can't remember lol)

16- Arcturus
12- Borknagar
16- Agalloch
10- Dan Swanö's Moontower
10- Devin Townsend Band
18- Edge of Sanity
12- Disillusion
12- Nightingale
11- Moonsorrow
12- Porcupine Tree
06- Solefald
17- Vintersorg

 

[Sadness and Hate]

Disillusion +2
Porcupine Tree -2

16- Arcturus
12- Borknagar
16- Agalloch
10- Dan Swanö's Moontower
10- Devin Townsend Band
18- Edge of Sanity
14- Disillusion
12- Nightingale
11- Moonsorrow
10- Porcupine Tree
06- Solefald
17- Vintersorg

 

[Lost_Orchid]

-2 Arcturus
+2 Vintersorg

14- Arcturus
12- Borknagar
16- Agalloch
10- Dan Swanö's Moontower
10- Devin Townsend Band
18- Edge of Sanity
14- Disillusion
12- Nightingale
11- Moonsorrow
10- Porcupine Tree
06- Solefald
19- Vintersorg

 

[Jude]

coming from the guy whos first post was

"But I don't know hardly anything about any of the other bands."

I do know that I have never heard any metal band (except Opeth) that is even in the same league as PT.

 

[Kenneth R.]

Porcupine Tree is metal?

 

[Black Paragon]

14- Arcturus
12- Borknagar
16- Agalloch
10- Dan Swanö's Moontower
10- Devin Townsend Band
18- Edge of Sanity
14- Disillusion
12- Nightingale
11- Moonsorrow
12- Porcupine Tree(+2)
04- Solefald(-2)
19- Vintersorg

There everything!

 

[Jude]

Porcupine Tree is metal?

No, they're not, that's why people were getting mad that they were beating every metal band on there.

Incidentally, the post I made late last night (2 minutes into today) was completely ignored by the next poster so I'm going to go ahead and vote again

14- Arcturus
12- Borknagar
16- Agalloch
10- Dan Swanö's Moontower
10- Devin Townsend Band
18- Edge of Sanity
14- Disillusion
12- Nightingale
11- Moonsorrow
14- Porcupine Tree(+2)
02- Solefald (-2)
19- Vintersorg

 

[MasterOLightning]

14- Arcturus
12- Borknagar
18- Agalloch (+2)
10- Dan Swanö's Moontower
08- Devin Townsend Band (-2)
18- Edge of Sanity
14- Disillusion
12- Nightingale
11- Moonsorrow
14- Porcupine Tree
02- Solefald
19- Vintersorg

 

[god dethroned]

16- Arcturus(+2)
12- Borknagar
18- Agalloch
10- Dan Swanö's Moontower
08- Devin Townsend Band
18- Edge of Sanity
14- Disillusion
12- Nightingale
11- Moonsorrow
12- Porcupine Tree(-2)
02- Solefald
19- Vintersorg

 

[Kenneth R.]

16- Arcturus
12- Borknagar
18- Agalloch
10- Dan Swanö's Moontower
08- Devin Townsend Band
18- Edge of Sanity
14- Disillusion
13- Nightingale +1
11- Moonsorrow
10- Porcupine Tree -2
03- Solefald +1
19- Vintersorg

Save Solefald

 

[Jude]

16- Arcturus
12- Borknagar
18- Agalloch
10- Dan Swanö's Moontower
08- Devin Townsend Band
18- Edge of Sanity
14- Disillusion
13- Nightingale +1
11- Moonsorrow
10- Porcupine Tree -2
03- Solefald +1
19- Vintersorg

Save Solefald

Bleh, I tried to get rid of them...I don't like them much at all.

 

[Kenneth R.]

I personally love every band on this list (unlike the other one) except Moonsorrow. I'm hitting PT because I know PT will wind up winning considering how many Opeth fans loooooove PT.

 

[EternalMetal]

I personally love every band on this list (unlike the other one) except Moonsorrow. I'm hitting PT because I know PT will wind up winning considering how many Opeth fans loooooove PT.

Why dont you read the posts? Everyone wants PT outta here, they arent metal and people are highly offended.

 

[Kenneth R.]

Why dont you read the posts? Everyone wants PT outta here, they arent metal and people are highly offended.

i'm not offended, but they had a major lead for a while. this is only fun when we *don't* know who will win. at least Opeth isn't on there

 

[EternalMetal]

i'm not offended, but they had a major lead for a while. this is only fun when we *don't* know who will win. at least Opeth isn't on there

I know, I was just being sarcastic. Everyone seems to be making a big deal about Porcupine Tree being on a list of metal bands. It was a stupid idea anyway, as the power of suggestion makes Porcupine Tree a top band among most Opeth fans.

From the trends I see on this forum, Agalloch are probably going to win.

 

[NicholasDWolfwood]

-2 Porcupine Tree
+2 Borknagar

=

16- Arcturus
14- Borknagar
18- Agalloch
10- Dan Swanö's Moontower
08- Devin Townsend Band
18- Edge of Sanity
14- Disillusion
13- Nightingale
11- Moonsorrow
08- Porcupine Tree
03- Solefald
19- Vintersorg