when vs the moor
- Thread starter Mr. Josey Wales
- Start date
all_sins_undone
New Metal Member
- Oct 5, 2005
- 4,933
- 7
- 0
wwallinga
Working on #3
wwallinga
Working on #3
IMO - Blackwater Park, When and The Moor (along with Deliverance, The Drapery Falls and Demon of the Fall) are all overrated because they have been played live recently.
The only song in the top 8 to not make a regular appearance in the set in Godhead's lament.
The only song in the top 8 to not make a regular appearance in the set in Godhead's lament.
wwallinga said:
I'm still hoping to hear that song live, being my favourite song and all. Maybe they'll play it on this tour :Spin:
But then again, if they don't come closer to Ottawa, I'm screwed because dad is a p3n0r and refuses to drive me anywhere that takes longer than 4 hours.
worldwide_suicide
Member
- Nov 27, 2005
- 1,811
- 1
- 38
hahahahahahahahahahhahahahaha
im not serious about anything, i decided to make it a big deal cuz i was bored, although i think when is better
im not serious about anything, i decided to make it a big deal cuz i was bored, although i think when is better
When is better than all but maybe 15 Opeth songs, The Moor is worse than all but maybe 15 Opeth songs. The final four suck balls. No Demon of the Fall is complete sacrelige.
porcupine_wolfff
Thick As A Brick
Powers
Good Morning USA!
When is a great song, but after learning to play it i sort of lost a bit of appreciation for it (that happens sometimes). I also dont think it has the same wonderful variation that the Moor does.
That being said... who cares, they're both awesome
I sometimes wonder at the point of these endless comparison threads...
That being said... who cares, they're both awesome
I sometimes wonder at the point of these endless comparison threads...
Powers
Good Morning USA!
I'd be prepared to class "When" as Opeth's anthem. Like "Ace of Spades" to Motorhead or "London Calling" to the Clash.
