Which version is better?

[CrazyClown]

I've mixed it for my friends, real drums and guitars and everything else.
so what i have
http://dl.dropbox.com/u/2653490/Steel0912-1.mp3

when i've replaced kick and snare, and used LeCto for guitars instead of real tracks.
http://dl.dropbox.com/u/2653490/Steel0912-2.mp3

So which versions guys do you like more?
any suggestions and advices are welcome!

 

[zer0_c00l]

I really like the real one! the only thing i didn't catch well was the kick, I think it's too much attackier. but maybe some compression will make him there!

 

[Revson]

I liked the replaced kick better than the original, but I still think it needs more punch to it. Either snare sound works well. I can't say I'm a big fan of either guitar sound though. It sounds like the real amp has the gain set too high to make it usable unless you got really drastic with the EQing. I'd say the LeCto track is the better of the two and with a little more tweaking it should be good to go.

Have you thought about blending the LeCto and the real track? Maybe set the LeCto to a lower gain and EQ differently so it takes care of the definition and the real amp gives the grungy distortion.

 

[CrazyClown]

Thanx guys.
Revson, i've tried blending, but it gaves me so much headache with phase issues.

 

[CrazyClown]

bump!