A/B ed5ted and UNedited project

[Arsenu,]

hey guys!

well this is my first time slip editing and boy do i want to kill myself right now...
iv'e edited the only the guitar tracks and it was a real bitch and took a lot of time but anyway i tought i'd upload the edited version and the unedited version for your comparison...

note that the drums are MIDI and the part which was edited was the guitars

edited version:

http://dl.dropbox.com/u/17437036/Humanit's Dusk EDITED.mp3

UNedited version:

http://dl.dropbox.com/u/17437036/Humanit's Dusk UNedited.mp3

enjoy!

 

[PhilR]

Both links are broken.... Still uploading?

 

[Arsenu,]

done uploading!

 

[Arsenu,]

i guess no one wants to say "that sounds bad..."

i know, it's only the EDITING i'm comparing, but OT nothing sounds good on cubase 5!
i think i'm going back to studio one... the only DAW so far iv'e got good results with

 

[prostetnic]

Good job on editing, I'm certainly no authority here but I think you did well. I hate how edited stuff sounds, I'd rather track guitars riff by riff (not note for note) until it's all acceptable takes, but I guess you don't always have the luxury of time/working with at least half-decent players

 

[Fama]

I guess the guitars are well edited, the machine gun snare is distracting =/ Also the bass drum sounds pretty bad.

 

[El_Gato]

The first rolls with the snare and oh's is not humanly possible.

More dynamics are needed.

Unedited version gave headache at second 7.

 

[arv_foh]

that kick sounds like a cardboard box, use a different sample.. why isn't there any bass guitar

 

[Arsenu,]

1. thanks guy!

2. you should really read what i wrote... the point here is NOT the sound. the drums will be recorded E drums by a human.
bass, well i intend to record, iv'e posted a thread that i'm looking for people to record bass for me and those who responded never did it, so i'm still looking!

3. i'll upload another A/B sample today which sounds better (!)

4. i know the intro drums are AWEFUL!

 

[Arsenu,]

and now, as i promised a couple of minutes ago, another part to compare:

this is the EDITED version

and this is the UNedited version

ENJOY!