Couldn't have said this any better.
POT is probably the heaviest album Anthrax has done and that has a non girly sounding Joey on it. In 1985 almost all Thrash singers were sounding girly. Joey proved on POT that he wasn't limited to singing that style of 80's thrash metal. He in no way sounded "Girly" on that album.
I'd take a girly sounding Joey era Anthrax that wrote thrash metal songs than a more alternative / grungy / generic power groove John Bush era any day of the week.
The band finally takes a step in the right direction toward going back to their Thrash roots by bringing back Joey and there are idiots like DMC that think that will make them 'girly' and less heavy
I can't wait for this donkeys who think Joey will still sound like he did on Spreading the Disease to hear the new material he is doing with Anthrax. They seem to forget the direction he was going vocally with POT.
Sometimes I wonder if these people actually ever even liked Anthrax. They want them to write a 'brutal thrash metal album' like Testament or Machine Head but that is just not their style. Go listen to those bands if you want that sound.
They might as well just get rid of Scott and Joey and bring in Eric Peterson and Chuck Billy