Band covering SX

[Matt]

You should like it for what it is, not dislike it for what it's not. Big deal the singer has too much vibrato, he still kicked ass.

I should.

But sadly, I can't.

 

[bball_1523]

You guys are being way too harsh. These guys are pretty amazing for how well they're covering Symphony X.

I agree, let's you see that are too harsh cover the same songs. lol

I think they did fine. Nobody's perfect.

 

[meisteh]

to i'm read trying your sentence hard but

 

[raythetse]

the singer had good tone, but he couldn't get nearly as high as russel allen.

the keyboards sounded good to me

the guitarist seems good, but he was having trouble with tempo on some solos, and that first solo in candlelight... bah

drums didn't cut it...

bass was good enough anyway...

overall though a good show, obviously no match for symphony x but good effort.

 

[Time-Machinist]

overall though a good show, obviously no match for symphony x but good effort.

If they'd been a match for S.X, they would not waste time with covering that much S.X. songs. I find them promising BTW... (And most probably they would be a lot better in time)

 

[OfSinsAndShred]

You guys are really tough to please! The singer couldn't get high notes, but on the rest of the stuff, he kicked ass - he really nailed "Out of the Ashes." Also, that guitarist could probably school half the guys on the forum.

 

[_Gentleman of_the Snow_]

Why is everybody ripping on the drummer? I thought he did a pretty awesome job

 

[rockyracoon]

Also, that guitarist could probably school half the guys on the forum.

Does that render their opinions invalid? If we all had to be as good as SX to critique SX then absolutely ZERO of us could open our mouths. So, when a band posts a performance online, they should be open to both positive and negative feedback. The musical prowess of the viewer(s) is beyond irrelevant.

 

[turke]

Well you know what they say (or you don't), if you don't like it, do the better of it

 

[AutumnGust]

I think it's very good covering! This singer is cool.

Hah! That fotage is better than any fotage of SX i've ever seen on the web lol, not counting the gigantour stuff...

 

[Roddoliver]

They are really good. The singer just does not sing as rough as Allen, but I think he did great.

 

[Flavio CotM]

You guys are being way too harsh. These guys are pretty amazing for how well they're covering Symphony X.

I agree, it's not easy to cover Symphony X, great effort IMO!!