Midian is my favourite cradle of filth cd by shit loads. Strong melodies, good dynamics, an excellent atmosphere and great imagry created by the lyrics/vocals are some of the things that make me like it so much. It's a bit more guitar and even metal focused than in particular cruelty and the beast and even all their albums before which is also good.
Damnation and a day i liked at first but the songs get kinda boring after a while.
Once again, I appreciate the increased focus on metal stylings (ie more riffs as opposed to tremlo picking), even over midian. However while they put more bite into the songs they lose alot the 'gothic' styling they once had. I guess some people would like that though. I'm not a fan of gothic music by any means (most of it bores the crap out of me) but i think it fitted with cradle very well. The dynamics on this cd don't come close to what was found on midian either. I think alot of bands are really ignoring the power of great dynamics these days which is kind of dissapointing because when you get this right it's when you get the best metal albums like master of puppets, still life, prometheus, dechristianize etc. Cradle's ability to create memorable dark melodies and mixing it with metal and dare i say it their imagry are what made this band so attractive to me in the first place. Take that away and you have a un-exciting average sounding band.
I think the drummer isn't too shabby on damnation and a day though despite the fact someone felt it necessary to point out how pathetic he is.
The last three real songs, in particular, 'The Smoke of her burning' are very good, as well as the instrumental 'the mordant liquor of tears'.