I gotta say Come my Fanatics. I feel like it's a bit less dense than Dopethrone and easier to listen to at any given time, plus there's the little matter of Wizard in Black...
I feel similarly about We Live as well, but that was my first Electric Wizard album.
Come My Fanatics. Dopethrone is very overrated IMO and I can't for the life of me understand why so many people think it is by far the best EW album. Jus' vocals are extremely distorted and grating and the so is the entire production.
Fanatics has a crushing production with clearer vocals and much more memorable riffs
Part of me thinks the album has taken on a life of it's own as an absolute classic. So much so that it's cool to worship it and the only answer to best EW album is "Dopethrone" without even thinking about it