FAVOURITE PORCUPINE TREE ALBUM

[Rocky Raccoon]

So which is it?

Mines In Absentia...

 

[Ken Lyall]

So which is it?

Mines In Absentia...

changes with the wind, but yes, In Absentia is really special
Signify comes close though

 

[Detric]

the sky moves sideways, simply amazing.

 

[Don Corleone]

in absentia.

but signify has a special place in my heart.

 

[arzachel]

yeah it's pretty much a toss between signify and In Absentia for me as well.

What the hell is metanoia doing up there btw?

 

[Rocky Raccoon]

Im still getting into Signify as I just brought it a few days ago...

 

[derbeder]

i went for deadwing. but i could have voted for in absentia instead.

 

[Rocky Raccoon]

yeah it's pretty much a toss between signify and In Absentia for me as well.

What the hell is metanoia doing up there btw?

I wasn't sure if it was an album or just a b sides collection or something so I put it up there just to be safe...

Im guessing its just live tracks or unreleased tracks or..?

 

[daz436]

i would say in absentia but its obviously gonna win so i voted for lightbulb sun in the hope it might make things slightly interesting

 

[WeepingMoon]

I agree with whoever said The Sky Moves Sideways is amazing. That album is pure spaced out rich textured music and just puts (me at least) in a special place when I listen to it. Not a lot of albums can do that.

Anyhow, I hardly ever have favourites for things, espescially music. So i'm not gonna vote. One minute I like The Sky Moves Sideways, next I like In Absentia, Lightbulb Sun, Up the Downstair etc etc. I have to say tho, that Deadwing will probably never be my favourite. not to say thats a bad record or anything, cuz when it came out I loved it and still do, but I just don't dig it as much as I do other PT albums in the long run.

 

[Don Corleone]

same here, weepingmoon. agreed on deadwing

 

[arzachel]

^^^^ yep. it's a collection of outtakes/improvisations recorded around the same time signify was.

 

[x_OPETH_x]

i had to pick Up The Downstair, simply because it was (and still is) completely original, and has the most "complete" sound to it, from beginning to end (not including Voyage 34)....

"Stars Die" should be on here as well...very good disc , even though it's a collection...

 

[wwallinga]

i went for deadwing. but i could have voted for in absentia instead.

+1

 

[NeverIsForever]

IA

 

[Prognostic]

daown the upstauir

 

[all_sins_undone]

daown the upstauir

Congrats

 

[Kenneth R.]

Lightbulb Sun.

followed by IA, DW.

 

[Evan84]

Lightbulb Sun

 

[Loeben]

Stupid Dream followed by On the Sunday of Life and In Absentia.

Even Less and Slave called Shiver are golden