Game: ultimate metal band 2007

QRV

historyphobic
Dec 8, 2005
872
0
16
41
cazandoelefantes.blogspot.com
Ok, so here are the rules:

1. Anyone can give +2 points and -2 points each day to any band of his/her choice. Deal with those points as you prefer, but do not exceed the 2 points limit.

2. To make things fair, for each positive point you give, you must also give a negative point.

3. We'll be dealing with whole points. You cannot give decimals.

4. Points are not accumulative. If you miss a day, you also miss the points you had the right to give that day. There's no "I didn't vote the past 3 days so I'll give 6 points on this round" sort of thing.

5. All bands start with a 10-point score. Any of them will be eliminated if it reaches the 0 points. However, to make things faster, if no band reaches 0 within 3 days time, the band with the lower score will go away. In the case of a tie, the next immediate vote will decide which band goes.

6. Time will be dealt with according to the hour set in the UM forums.


So, here's the final list of 20 bands, made according to the suggestions given in the other thread. I've already given and taken my points of the day:

10 - Samael
10 - Kamelot
10 - Paradise Lost
10 - Thyrfing
10 - Borknagar
10 - Vital Remains
10 - Decapitated
10 - At the Gates
10 - Dissection
10 - Agalloch
10 - Disilussion
10 - The Kovenant
09 - Evanescence (-1)
09 - Linkin Park (-1)
11 - Swallow the Sun (+1)
10 - Root
11 - Neurosis (+1)
10 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar
10 - Omnius Grief
 
11 - Samael (+1)
10 - Kamelot
11 - Paradise Lost (+1)
10 - Thyrfing
10 - Borknagar
10 - Vital Remains
10 - Decapitated
10 - At the Gates
10 - Dissection
10 - Agalloch
10 - Disilussion
10 - The Kovenant
09 - Evanescence
07 - Linkin Park (-2)
11 - Swallow the Sun
10 - Root
11 - Neurosis
10 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar
10 - Omnius Grief


Edit: Take the time to check in case you posted almost at the same time as another user: if you ended up second and your vote is now incongruous with the sequence, please edit your post to reflect the changes others made.
 
11 - Samael
10 - Kamelot
11 - Paradise Lost
10 - Thyrfing
10 - Borknagar
10 - Vital Remains
10 - Decapitated
11 - At the Gates (+1)
11 - Dissection (+1)
10 - Agalloch
10 - Disilussion
10 - The Kovenant
08 - Evanescence (-1)
06 - Linkin Park (-1)
11 - Swallow the Sun
10 - Root
11 - Neurosis
10 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar
10 - Omnius Grief
 
oh, you didnt include Moonsorrow in the end?

11 - Samael
10 - Kamelot
11 - Paradise Lost
11 - Thyrfing (+1)
11 - Borknagar (+1)
10 - Vital Remains
10 - Decapitated
11 - At the Gates
11 - Dissection (+1)
10 - Agalloch
10 - Disilussion
10 - The Kovenant
07 - Evanescence (-1)
05 - Linkin Park (-1)
11 - Swallow the Sun
10 - Root
11 - Neurosis
10 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar
10 - Omnius Grief
 
11 - Samael
10 - Kamelot
11 - Paradise Lost
11 - Thyrfing
11 - Borknagar
10 - Vital Remains
10 - Decapitated
11 - At the Gates
11 - Dissection
10 - Agalloch
12 - Disilussion (+1)(+1)
10 - The Kovenant
06 - Evanescence (-1)
04 - Linkin Park (-1)
11 - Swallow the Sun
10 - Root
11 - Neurosis
10 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar
10 - Omnius Grief
 
11 - Samael
10 - Kamelot
11 - Paradise Lost
11 - Thyrfing
11 - Borknagar
10 - Vital Remains
11 - Decapitated(+1)
11 - At the Gates
11 - Dissection
10 - Agalloch
12 - Disilussion
10 - The Kovenant
06 - Evanescence
02 - Linkin Park (-2)
12 - Swallow the Sun(+1)
10 - Root
11 - Neurosis
10 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar
10 - Omnius Grief
 
12 - Samael +1
11 - Kamelot +1
11 - Paradise Lost
11 - Thyrfing
11 - Borknagar
10 - Vital Remains
11 - Decapitated
11 - At the Gates
11 - Dissection
10 - Agalloch
12 - Disilussion
10 - The Kovenant
06 - Evanescence
00 - Linkin Park -2
12 - Swallow the Sun
10 - Root
11 - Neurosis
10 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar
10 - Omnius Grief
 
I'm not sure how exactly a new 'round' is started, but I'll assume I can just drop LP off the list and do my +/- 2 bit.

12 - Samael
10 - Kamelot -1
11 - Paradise Lost
11 - Thyrfing
11 - Borknagar
10 - Vital Remains
11 - Decapitated
11 - At the Gates
11 - Dissection
10 - Agalloch
12 - Disilussion
12 - The Kovenant +2
05 - Evanescence -1
12 - Swallow the Sun
10 - Root
11 - Neurosis
10 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar
10 - Omnius Grief

~kov.
 
Hehe, Linkin Park went fast. I dont really understand what is Root doing here. The worst (Czech) metal band ever.

12 - Samael
10 - Kamelot
11 - Paradise Lost
11 - Thyrfing
11 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains (+2)
11 - Decapitated
11 - At the Gates
11 - Dissection
10 - Agalloch
12 - Disilussion
12 - The Kovenant
05 - Evanescence
12 - Swallow the Sun
08 - Root (-2)
11 - Neurosis
10 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar
10 - Omnius Grief
 
Oh, Silly Me! I Mispelled "Ominous Grief" as "Omnius Grief" in the proposal thread and now it appears mispelled in every post here.

(It strikes me as odd that nobody noticed it)
 
12 - Samael
10 - Kamelot
13 - Paradise Lost (+2)
11 - Thyrfing
11 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains
11 - Decapitated
11 - At the Gates
11 - Dissection
10 - Agalloch
12 - Disilussion
12 - The Kovenant
03 - Evanescence (-2)
12 - Swallow the Sun
08 - Root
11 - Neurosis
10 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar
10 - Omnius Grief
 
13 - Samael (+1)
10 - Kamelot
13 - Paradise Lost
11 - Thyrfing
11 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains
11 - Decapitated
11 - At the Gates
11 - Dissection
11 - Agalloch (+1)
12 - Disilussion
12 - The Kovenant
01 - Evanescence (-2)
12 - Swallow the Sun
08 - Root
11 - Neurosis
10 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar
10 - Ominous Grief
 
13 - Samael
10 - Kamelot
12 - Paradise Lost (-1)
11 - Thyrfing
11 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains
11 - Decapitated
13 - At the Gates (+2)
11 - Dissection
11 - Agalloch
12 - Disilussion
12 - The Kovenant
00 - Evanescence (-1)
12 - Swallow the Sun
08 - Root
11 - Neurosis
10 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar
10 - Ominous Grief
 
13 - Samael
10 - Kamelot
11 - Paradise Lost (-1)
11 - Thyrfing
11 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains
10 - Decapitated (-1)
13 - At the Gates
11 - Dissection
11 - Agalloch
12 - Disilussion
12 - The Kovenant
14 - Swallow the Sun (+2)
08 - Root
11 - Neurosis
10 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar
10 - Ominous Grief
 
12 - Samael (-1)
09 - Kamelot (-1)
11 - Paradise Lost
11 - Thyrfing
12 - Borknagar (+1)
12 - Vital Remains
10 - Decapitated
14 - At the Gates (+1)
11 - Dissection
11 - Agalloch
12 - Disilussion
12 - The Kovenant
14 - Swallow the Sun
08 - Root
11 - Neurosis
10 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar
10 - Ominous Grief
 
12 - Samael
09 - Kamelot
11 - Paradise Lost
11 - Thyrfing
12 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains
10 - Decapitated
14 - At the Gates
11 - Dissection
13 - Agalloch +2
10 - Disilussion -2
12 - The Kovenant
14 - Swallow the Sun
08 - Root
11 - Neurosis
10 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar
10 - Ominous Grief
 
12 - Samael
09 - Kamelot
11 - Paradise Lost
11 - Thyrfing
12 - Borknagar
12 - Vital Remains
10 - Decapitated
16 - At the Gates (+2)
11 - Dissection
12 - Agalloch (-1)
10 - Disilussion
12 - The Kovenant
13 - Swallow the Sun (-1)
08 - Root
11 - Neurosis
10 - Marduk
10 - Naglfar
10 - Ominous Grief

No one shall beat At the Gates!