Personal opinion on Horror Show...IE's worst. Not as inconsistent as SWTWC, but the good isn't near as good.
Wolf: Feh. If you're gonna play fast, play fast, don't just mess around with fast riffs in slow time signatures. Crappy, crappy chorus.
Damien: Would be quite awesome if not for the really repetitive riff & overlong chorus. And that midle section is stupid, stupid, STUPID.
Jack: Very good tune, but the riff is again repetitive. But playing fast always helps.
Ghost of Freedom: Unspeakably sappy and hideous.
Im-ho-tep: Another great song ruined by a repetitive riff and forced down to merely "pretty good." Awesome chorus.
Jeckyl & Hyde: Boring. Next track.
Dragon's Child: Even more boring. Next next track.
Transylvania: It's a great Maiden instrumental, but there is NO FUCKING DIFFERENCE. Jon's Maiden worship is really hurting. Next next next track.
Frankenstein: See Im-Ho-Tep. Cool screams.
Dracula: HELL MOTHERFUCKING YES!! Good melodic intro, KILLER FUCKING SHRIEKS!! Thrash all the way through, and great thrash.
Phantom Opera Ghost: I hate, loathe, detest, despise, and wish to destroy keyboards. A great song that would be utterly brilliant if they A) took out the keyboards B) replaced the long riff-repeat sections with a couple of lead breaks, or at least varied the riffage. Those parts are really boring as is; otherwise, great.