Guitars recorded with reel amp - Need criticism!

[AntonFranzon]

Guitars recorded - Orange Jim Roots amp - Orange 4x12 cab - Sm57
This is one song of my bands upcoming EP, so we're going to record some vocals and re-master it very soon.
I'm going to work with the EQing when the vocals are recorded so I can mix them smooooooooth
What do you think of the mix/guitar tone so far?

 

[benjy]

Tone is fine but the guitar is a bit weak. Have you recorded bass? No to be a dick but your kick is absolute shit. That is what really needs the most work but I like the guitar tone. I think if you beef it up and get a better kick with some more low end it will be pretty rad. I like the song btw.

 

[tmitchell33]

In my opinion the whole mix (Especially the guitars) sound really scooped and the drums sound like a superior drummer preset. The second one has a really unpleasant fizz in the guitars, the kick is improved in the second but there is a dangerous low end in there, just be careful how low you are boosting. Good start but need some TLC.

 

[alternateadrian]

The first one sounds thin and artificial.