Hence the hint to the fact that I had more than one mic on everything. I had a TLM103 in the corner of the room for all of the takes for each instrument. A Rode NT-2A worked nicely on everything directly, and a KSM44 as well. I know I had a couple of others, including a dynamic mic on something, but I can't remember which one and I'm pretty sure it wasn't the SM57.
~006