I'm as a big a Matthew Barlow fan as there is. To my ear, he sang with more passion and intensity than anyone (short of maybe Tate in his prime). However, I thought Tim was excellent live. Granted, he can't pull off Matt's songs the way Matt can, but I didn't expect he would be able to. There are things that Tim does that I'm quite sure Matt would struggle with. Seeing "Gettysburg" live, was worth the price of admission (both times). I would love to see IE rip the roof off of Eathlink Live.
Zod