Impulse vs Cab (in the mix)

[Line666]

Yeah it's all very well to say that but you defeated the point of the test by using a machine to do what your ears should be telling you then blowing the results early. Anyone can achieve a logical outcome in that scenario, that's not interesting, what is interesting is whether people can get there by finesse alone.

Anyway whilst I can abstain from reading the thread, I was more interested in other peoples results which, if the answer is already out prematurely, could be considered skewered.

 

[locus_coeruleus]

If you want to actually do a blind test, then just don't read the comments before posting.

Yeah, anyway there's no real way to do a blind test on the internet as anyone can analyze the files and "guess" which is which, so I don't believe anyone telling me they could tell 320 from wav.

 

[lolzgreg]

I think I want to do this test soon with my rig. As soon as I have some time.

On any note, you can just about always distinguish a real amp from an impulse by listening for a certain kind of fizz-haze that's only on real mic'd tones that adds a certain amount of air to the tone.

 

[Skinny Viking]

Its not WE though. Its a small group of very militant people.
I will do another in the mix test myself, so that I know that everything has been done correct. German correctness, you know?

kinda militant of you wa?

 

[Skaldir]

kinda militant of you wa?

Haha, yes. But please don't add new fuel do this whole shitstorm. And don't mess with Germans
Although today I feel like spreading love somehow.