ThePhobiac
be at ease
From the very beginning to the final strains, melody defines this album. Even if it's melody played on synth that the purists will hate, or vocal melodies that just seems to be expanding on In Flames' musical repertoire. This was the same on TJR, Whoracle, Colony and Clayman: and THAT is why I feel this album can stand proud as the best In Flames release since that era. Stand out tracks for me are the title track, All For Me (has strains of Gyroscope written all over it to my ears) Fear is the Weakness (love that synth line, gives me some crazy beautiful mental images), The Attic (the haunted feel is really something special) Ropes (Bjorn is no fucking slouch, really upbeat and inspirational too) Enter Tragedy (hearing it in CD quality really brought out the power, it's the closest thing on this album to Artifacts of the Black Rain) and A New Dawn (obviously a masterpiece as previously discussed by pretty much everyone).
Yes, glad to see I wasn't the only one who got a Gyroscope vibe from All For Me! And that's not a hit against Gyroscope, either, or a strained attempt to compare the two eras, that was a legitimate, spontaneous feeling. You're right that melody seems to be at the very core of this album, whereas R2R through ASOP didn't have that "element" to it (though I feel ASOP came very close).
Now that I'm relistening to the album, I have to say Anders might actually be one of my favorite aspects, whereas usually I tune him out, especially on albums like Whoracle. His cleans are inoffensive and compliment the music well this time around. I was transcribing the lyrics a while ago in Microsoft Word, and I was pretty damn impressed at some points.