OzNimbus said:
The stock 5150 cab sucks harder than Jenna Jameson.
Let me rephrase that. I've found the Sheffield cab to be extremely bright. Of course, I'm talking miked up.... not in the room. I've had FAR better results recording a 5150 thru a V30 cab than with a Sheffield. YMMV.
Are you sure you have the 5150 cab and not some other Peavey deal loaded up with something else?
There are other Peavey speakers called "Sheffield" but they aren't the same as go in the 5150 cabs.
Anyhow - when I plug anything else into my 5150 cab (which was bought in '95, so maybe the new ones are different... I dunno...) all the high end vanishes. Sucked away...
Plug a 5150 into just about anything else (and most of my "anything else" experience has been with Vintage 30 equipped cabs...) and the high end will peel your face off.
And as for "in the room" vs. "miced up" you're throwing me for a loop.
In my experience the best recorded guitar tones come from a rig that sounds just like you want it to sound IN THE ROOM. The guitar player has to be happy with the way the guitar plugged into the amp sounds before you do anything on the recording side of things.
I get that in no time at all with my 5150 or 5150-II running thru my stock 5150 slant cab. The challenge is to get that sound onto tape.
Maybe you're sticking with the tried & true which works for most amps, I find it very difficult to capture the 5150 tone with an SM-57. Maybe that's part of your problem, because the 57 puts an annoying buzz up in the high end that you can't EQ out. The only time I've been happy micing my cab with a 57 was when I was running it through a Vintech 473. I'm guessing some combination of the transformer and the "neve-guts" in that box had a natural way of taming the shrill high end.
With any other mic pre (from Class-A Avalon stuff down to Mackie XDR...) I've always gotten much better results recording with either a Sennheiser 409 or a 609. It doesn't add all that crap to the high mids that the 57 has.
If you haven't tried it, you should give it a shot.
I prefer to track my guitars as clean as possible - not talking about gain or distortion, but I want the sound there from the beginning. If you add console EQ while you're tracking or do anything other than some hi-pass while mixing then the tone gets changed too much by the phase shifts introduced by the EQ.
Check out the tracks from the other thread I posted about a needing a singer - they were all recorded with the 57 thru the Vintech 473. Two rhythm guitars panned hard L&R and up to 8 harmony tracks over top - check out the end of the one called "Five Song" for a good example of where that many tracks of the stock 5150 cab still doesn't get shrill like you're saying.
If you do happen to check that track out, just do your best to ignore the overdub at the beginning which was played on a guitar with less-than-stellar intonation. Ah, the hazards of adding parts when your ears are 12 hours past being tired...
Again, just my 2 cents...
ryan