Isis review on SSMT

I've never seen a Isis review non favorable to it...neither a review which is not praising them
It's always like:
- A Masterpiece that transcent music itself or
- Best metal album ever released (from a staff review on Ultimatemetal)
- etc.
 
"The vocals are straight out of Neurosis' realm of lung shredding, deliberately tuneless yelling".

Lung shredding, yes. Tuneless? Definetely not. He yells certain notes pertaining to the rest of the song, and he nails it live too.

He also has semi-clean vocals here and there.