Since everyone else who's a Gen.Discussion regular has chimed in, might as well throw my $.02 in as well.
I thoroughly read through the entire site.
One word review: stupid.
Sorry, but that's the case. I'm not maladjusted. I'm not a neophyte. I'm not mindlessly ignorant. Nor am I unintelligent. This site was CLEARLY written by those with a decent grasp of the metal world, and I AGREE that we metalheads are so damned easy to poke fun at.
But everyone seems to be missing the point here: IT WASN'T FUCKING FUNNY. I'd love to read a site that poked fun AND was actually funny. This was just stupid, plain and simple. I think I chuckled a couple times at the logo-deciphering, and even then it was only at the sheer ludicrous of the names. Oh yeah, I did laugh out loud at the description of the prog-metal geeks. Now THAT was funny.